Skip to main content

Cookies on BBB.org

We use cookies to give users the best content and online experience. By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to allow us to use all cookies. Visit our Privacy Policy to learn more.

Manage Cookies

Auto Insurance Near You

Being insured is an essential part of car ownership. Auto insurance can cover the cost of damages and repairs to your car and injuries from a crash. In addition, it offers financial protection if you are held responsible for someone else’s injuries or damages. Different insurance policies have different coverages, and several factors determine how much you’ll pay.

To find auto insurance near you, search the list below. To see only BBB Accredited Businesses in your search results, use the filter or look for the BBB Seal.

Filter by

Filter by

Distance
Categories
BBB Rating
State/Province
Sort By
  • Distance
  • Rating

Search results

Alain Blackley: Allstate Insurance

Insurance Agent, Insurance Companies, Auto Insurance ...

not BBB accredited
(614) 300-7779

4450 Kenny Rd,
Columbus, OH 43220

Keith Baggs: Allstate Insurance

Insurance Agent, Insurance Companies, Auto Insurance ...

not BBB accredited
(614) 878-9266

4937 W Broad St,
Columbus, OH 43228

Allstate Insurance Agency JC Prime Insurance and Financial Group

Insurance Companies, Insurance Services Office, Homeowners Insurance ...

BBB Rating: C-

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • AK
  • AL
  • AR
  • AS
  • AZ
  • CA
  • CO
  • CT
  • DC
  • DE
  • FL
  • GA
  • GU
  • HI
  • IA
  • ID
  • IL
  • IN
  • KS
  • KY
not BBB accredited
(847) 402-5000

3492 Snouffer Rd., Ste. 210,
Columbus, OH 43235

State Farm Insurance Company

Insurance Companies, Auto Insurance, Life Insurance ...

BBB Rating: F

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • IL
not BBB accredited
(800) 782-8332

3468 N High St,
Columbus, OH 43214

Grange Enterprise Companies, including Grange and Integrity Insurance

Insurance Companies, Insurance Services Office, Homeowners Insurance ...

BBB Rating: A+

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • GA
  • IA
  • IL
  • IN
  • KY
  • MI
  • MN
  • OH
  • PA
  • SC
  • TN
  • VA
  • WI
Accredited BusinessAccredited Business
(800) 422-0550

PO Box 25195,
Columbus, OH 43216

Get a Quote

Michael Williams: Allstate Insurance

Insurance Agent, Insurance Companies, Auto Insurance ...

BBB Rating: A+
not BBB accredited
(614) 299-7000

246 Lincoln Cir,
Gahanna, OH 43230

Robert Brown II: Allstate Insurance

Insurance Agent, Insurance Companies, Auto Insurance ...

not BBB accredited
(614) 349-4499

1000 High St,
Worthington, OH 43085

Alex Ottney-State Farm Agency

Insurance Companies, Auto Insurance, Life Insurance ...

BBB Rating: F

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • IL
not BBB accredited
(800) 782-8332

3468 N High St,
Columbus, OH 43214

Allstate Agency - Nathan Drury

Insurance Companies, Insurance Services Office, Homeowners Insurance ...

BBB Rating: C-

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • AK
  • AL
  • AR
  • AS
  • AZ
  • CA
  • CO
  • CT
  • DC
  • DE
  • FL
  • GA
  • GU
  • HI
  • IA
  • ID
  • IL
  • IN
  • KS
  • KY
not BBB accredited
(847) 402-5000

1108 N High Street,
Columbus, OH 43201

Gallagher

Insurance Companies, Insurance Services Office, Homeowners Insurance ...

BBB Rating: A+

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • AK
  • AL
  • AR
  • AS
  • AZ
  • CA
  • CO
  • CT
  • DC
  • DE
  • FL
  • GA
  • GU
  • HI
  • IA
  • ID
  • IL
  • IN
  • KS
  • KY
Accredited BusinessAccredited Business
(630) 773-3800

875 N High St,
Columbus, OH 43215

Get a Quote

AssuredPartners of Ohio, LLC

Insurance Agency, Insurance Companies, Insurance Services Office ...

BBB Rating: A-

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
not BBB accredited
(614) 224-0772

1349 W Lane Ave Ste 900,
Columbus, OH 43221

Dan Coonfare Agency, LLC

Insurance Agency, Insurance Companies, Insurance Services Office ...

BBB Rating: A+
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • OH
not BBB accredited
(614) 486-5400

1080 Fishinger Rd,
Columbus, OH 43221-2302

The Heights Insurance Agency

Insurance Agent, Insurance Companies, Auto Insurance ...

BBB Rating: A+
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • Franklin County, OH
  • Columbus, OH
  • New Albany, OH
  • Pickerington, OH
  • 43212
  • 43220
  • 43221
  • USA
Accredited BusinessAccredited Business
(614) 381-7078

1286 West Lane Ave, 1st Floor,
Columbus, OH 43221

Get a Quote

Detwiler-Brofford Insurance, Inc.

Insurance Services Office, Homeowners Insurance, Auto Insurance ...

BBB Rating: A+

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • OH
Accredited BusinessAccredited Business
(614) 471-4888

130 E Chestnut St Ste 200,
Columbus, OH 43215-2598

Get a Quote

Nationwide

Insurance Companies, Financial Services, Insurance Services Office ...

BBB Rating: A+

This rating reflects BBB's opinion about the entire organization's interactions with its customers, including interactions with local locations.

View HQ Business Profile
Service Area

Serving the following areas:

  • AK
  • AL
  • AR
  • AZ
  • CA
  • CO
  • CT
  • DC
  • DE
  • FL
  • GA
  • HI
  • IA
  • ID
  • IL
  • IN
  • KS
  • KY
  • LA
  • MA
Accredited BusinessAccredited Business
(877) 669-6877

3 Nationwide Plz,
Columbus, OH 43215-2410

Get a Quote
Next page

Show me search results for:

You can change this selection at any time via the Accredited Business toggle on the search results page.

More information on finding auto insurance you can trust

Having auto insurance is most often a requirement to register your vehicle with your state or province. Regardless of the requirement, auto insurance gives drivers a sense of safety when on the road. Insurance pays for car damage and medical expenses if you’re hurt in an accident.

To find insurance, you’ll need your personal information and details about your vehicle, including your driver’s license and your car’s VIN number, mileage, make, model, and year.

It’s always a good idea to get quotes from several insurers to find the most affordable coverage. A good rule of thumb is to get at least three insurance quotes or estimates. Consider national, regional, and local brokers when shopping around for insurance options. NerdWallet shared that smaller, regional insurers may have lower rates than national ones.

Various factors determine how much you’ll pay for car insurance. Consumer Reports shared that insurance agencies look at your driver profile (your age, driving experience, and history), the type of car you own (the more expensive the car, the more you’ll pay for insurance), your credit history, and external conditions that pertain to where you live.

If you’re looking for additional ways to save on your auto coverage, consider driving a car that’s cheaper to insure, increasing your deductible, and improving your credit.

When comparing quotes between insurance agencies, consider discounts you can take advantage of and add-ons or extra coverage options, like comprehensive coverage, collision coverage, uninsured motorist coverage, and more. Depending on your situation, you may or may not need every type of coverage the insurer provides. Choose the policy that best meets your coverage needs and monthly payment budget.

If your auto insurance rate ever increases, it could be for various reasons, most of which are tied to risk and liability. If you receive any traffic violations, are involved in an accident (whether it’s your fault or not), or file a comprehensive claim, you could see your rate go up. Your age can also play a role once you reach your 70s. In addition, adding more vehicles and drivers to your policy can hike up the price.

If you’re renting a car, your personal auto insurance might extend to cover the rental. It all depends on your current coverage policy. Contact your insurance agent to ask whether your current policy covers a rental car.

During your search for auto insurance coverage, find a broker you can trust. Look online at customer reviews to get an idea of customer satisfaction with the company and its insurance agents. You can also ask friends and family for recommendations, especially if you are considering a local or regional insurance company.

To find BBB Accredited auto insurance companies, look for the BBB Seal. These trusted businesses have been vetted against BBB’s Standards for Trust.

For more tips on managing your auto ownership, visit BBB’s Auto HQ. Learn more about what you should keep in mind when buying any kind of insurance, and find more tips on buying auto insurance.