BBB Scam Tracker
Back to search
This content is based on victim and potential victim accounts. Government agencies and legitimate business names and phone numbers are often used by scam artists to take advantage of people.
Description
I filled out information on affordablehealthcare.gov and I immediately started receiving calls. I answered a call from someone who told me they can help me obtain health insurance. We were on the phone for about an hour going over the details of different policies I could obtain. The agent identified himself as Eugene Sullivan from Preferred Health Insurance Agency. I agreed on a plan and told him not to take money out of my account until December 15, 2025 (the alleged insurance was supposed to go into effect Jan 1, 2026) I printed out some information that he emailed me and I started to realize something felt off and it wasn't a plan I was comfortable obtaining so I called Eugene Sullivan. He didn't answer but he text me back saying he would call me back in a few minutes, which he did. I asked him a couple questions about the policy and I told him I didn't feel the policy fit my needs so I told him I wanted to cancel. He immediately said, "Thanks for wasting my time, have a good day." I called the 800 number on the paperwork to make sure the policy got cancelled and I did receive an e-mail back saying the policy was cancelled. I woke up today to find a charge for the first month payment for the insurance taken out of my account. Mind you, I told him not to take payment until December 15, 2025. I realized he had put the charge through on the day that I cancelled. Luckily I caught it while the transaction was still pending, I was able to stop payment on it. I can't believe I fell for this.
Dollars Lost
$593.99
Targeted Person's Location
MI, USA - 48042
Scam Type
Online Purchase
Learn More
Business name
Preferred Health Insurance Agency
Date Reported
November 22, 2025
Scam ID
1112342
Tell us what happened
Your input keeps Scam Tracker accurate and useful for the next person who searches this scam.
Are you the business named in this report? Dispute this report.