Reviews

Review Details

• Review fromJohn Z

  Date: 04/16/2025

  5 stars
  Super, super people and company to do business with. I sent ****** a list of about 250 slabbed coins I was wanting to sell. He got back to me within just a couple of hours with a very fair offer. I shipped them off and the funds were in my checking account I believe the day or day after they received the coins. I cannot recommend this company highly enough.

• Review fromJoan M

  Date: 03/13/2025

  5 stars
  I had such a wonderful experience selling my coins to Coinfully. They were recommended through a ****** search and I am so glad I found them. Everyone I dealt with on the phone was very knowledgeable and kind. It is a rarity these days to find a business you are so comfortable working with. They are very honest and helpful.

• Review fromBarbara Z

  Date: 02/06/2025

  5 stars
  ***** and ****** were incredibly helpful, understanding, and patient throughout the process. My past experiences selling coins werent great, but Coinfully made the process transparent and easy. I highly recommend their service.

• Review fromSuzanne C

  Date: 01/15/2025

  5 stars
  I am so happy with the service I got from Coinfully. They were fast in giving me a quote for my coins. The process was very professional and fast. I plan to use their services again as well as recommend them to my friends and relative.

• Review fromSusan W

  Date: 01/13/2025

  5 stars
  I am very satisfied and happy with my Coinfully experience! Bottom line, I feel I received a very good valuation of my collection and the process was relatively easy for a task that was very overwhelming at times! Not knowing much about the industry and hesitant to do business with an online entity I knew nothing about, I was skeptical. But ****** is knowledgeable and responsive and helped every step of the way. He gave me equal and sometimes better quotes than local people I visited. I also was interrupted many times on my end, so it took a while to finalize. I never felt pressured to hurry, which I appreciated. Once the price was agreed upon, mailing the collection was easy and payment was prompt and easy to receive. All in all, a very good experience and I firmly recommend ****** & the Coinfully team!

• Review fromMolly N

  Date: 12/23/2024

  5 stars
  I am very happy with the service I received at Coinfully, and I'm glad I found them! I inherited coins from my father and grandfather. They were important to them, so while I'm not a collector myself, I wanted to make sure I treated them with respect when selling. That of course includes getting the best value out of them as possible. The highest price will usually come from a direct sale to another collector. I will do that with some of these coins, but I also had larger lots of coins that I didn't feel I had the time nor expertise to market. I compared the Coinfully offer to my local coin shop, and across the board, Coinfully was better. Everyone was communicative and helpful, and there was never any pressure. I took my time making my decision, and I'm confident I made the right one. Thanks to ******** Braden, and ****** for the help!

• Review fromJon P

  Date: 10/16/2024

  5 stars
  Ive had the pleasure of working with the team at Coinfully on several occasions. They have staff that have been able to assist me in various areas. From selling gold I had to estimating value on coins. They could handle it all everything felt very upfront and transparent. Which put me at ease. They were kind and direct with offers explaining up to date information that got them to the offer.I send everyone I know to Coinfully. I dont feel like anyone will get a better more up to date offer or a kinder experience.

• Review fromDanielle M

  Date: 08/30/2024

  5 stars

  Danielle M

  Date: 08/30/2024

  After my grandpa passed away, my grandma was left with a valuable collection of silver coins.She had no idea what to do with it so I helped her with the project.I am so happy that I discovered Coinfully, they made the process so easy.The collection ended up being worth more than I thought and we received a wire transfer as soon as they had the coins.
  

  Coinfully

  Date: 09/05/2024

  Thank you so much for your note! We are so glad we were able to be of service to your and your family. Best, Coinfully

• Review fromTim M

  Date: 08/07/2024

  2 stars

  Tim M

  Date: 08/07/2024

  I got an offer from Coinfully of $485 for a coin I wanted to sell. I took it to a local reputable coin shop in town and was given $560 cash.It was well worth the trip. Don't be lazy, people!
  

  Coinfully

  Date: 08/15/2024

  Thank you for telling us about your experience ***! Our transparent approach to appraisals is built for comparison, always giving our clients time to find out if another firm is a better fit. Happy to provide a little more color here for your bullion coin:Gold prices change everyday with the live market, by getting a second opinion after 8/6 you were able to take advantage of a great gold price rally. We update our offers on daily gold prices when clients let us know they would like to move forward.On the day we appraised the item, the retail value for your piece was $570. Our offer was $485 which includes our 15% fee. On any pieces a coin shop may have specific collectors that are willing to pay over market price and we are thrilled you found the right match.