This Business Is Not BBB Accredited

Buckeye's Finest Foods

Buckeye's Finest Foods

(440) 723-5153

Buckeye's Finest Foods

4282 E Lake Rd
Sheffield Lk, OH 44054-1248
Additional Phone Numbers
  • (479) 200-2261
  • (614) 607-2801
  • (440) 457-7564
  • (614) 400-9513
Additional Email Addresses
BBB File Opened: 01/27/2016
Business Management
  • Mr. James Stewart, Owner
  • Mr. Anthony J.
  • Mr. Eric Robinson
Business Category
  • Meat Sales



Information involving this firm's unauthorized use of the BBB logo, its advertising, and concerns about its physical location are included in this review.

Advertising Review

In June 2016, BBB contacted this firm concerning the following advertising claims on its website:

"100% Satisfaction Guarantee"
"Our Guarantee: Our products are USDA inspected. We Guarantee taste, tenderness, flavor, and freshness for up to one year in the freezer. If you are not satisfied, we will promptly replace or exchange your unused products"

"Lowest Case Prices In The Industry."

The BBB Code of Advertising states that advertisers should only u... Read More


This company first came the attention of the Cleveland BBB in June of 2016.  At that time a Maple Heights woman reported purchasing meat and chicken from a representative who was going door-to-door in the neighborhood on Father's Day weekend.

BBB has confirmed the company failed to get required registration in Maple Heights to solicit door-to-door.  

The company’s address in Avon Lake is a UPS Store mail forwarding service and the Garfield Hts. location is the former address of  the website registrant.  

Mail to the Avon Lake address has been returned as not deliverable and with no forwarding address.  As of July 1, 2016, the physical location of the company is uncertain.

The company's contract also fails to include a three day cancellation clause as required by law.

BBB cautions consumers to be wary of door-to-door vendors selling food products.

     * Before agreeing to purchase, check the seller’s rating at  If no information is available call 216-241-7678 and ask a representative to investigate further.  Also research the company online.

     * Contact the local health department to confirm the company has proper licensing and check with your local city authorities to determine if a solicitor’s permit was obtained.

     * Get literature from the business.  Does it have its physical address and phone number?  Call the number.  Are you able to speak to anyone or do you just get voice mail?  
     * Ask to view the meat that is on the truck.  Is the truck refrigerated?  Is the meat properly labeled?

     * Don't feel pressured into making a decision.

Note: The Ohio Department of Agriculture advises consumers to beware of any dealer who wants you to purchase bulk quantities of meat and poultry that are not properly labeled. Always ask the dealer to leave the box or labeling information if individual products are not labeled.

BBB Reason for Ratings

BBB rating is based on 13 factors: Get the details about the factors considered.

Factors that affect the rating for Buckeye's Finest Foods include:

  • Length of time business has been operating
  • Failure to respond to 2 complaint(s) filed against business
  • Advertising issues found by BBB
  • Unauthorized use of BBB name or trademarks

Licensing information is provided in the BBB Business Profiles to inform the public about industries that may require professional licensing, bonding, or registration. Better Business Bureau encourages you to check with the appropriate agency to be certain any requirements are currently being met.
BBB promotes truth in advertising by contacting advertisers whose claims conflict with the BBB Code of Advertising. These claims come to our attention from our internal review of advertising, consumer complaints and competitor challenges. BBB asks advertisers to substantiate their claims, change ads to make offers more clear to consumers, and remove misleading or deceptive statements.
BBB reports on known significant government actions involving the business's marketplace conduct.
BBB reports on a company that is out of business for one year from the date the company closes its doors or ceases to do business.
BBB reports on unauthorized use of the Better Business Bureau's name and/or logo for as long as the business continues to use it in any advertising, or for one year after the business ceases any repeated unauthorized uses.
BBB reports on a business’s bankruptcy as long as the business remains in bankruptcy.
BBB reports when mail sent to the business was returned by the Postal Service.

Buckeye's Finest Foods

This Business Is Not BBB Accredited

Buckeye's Finest Foods

Customer Review Rating:

There are NO reviews for this business.
Be the first to leave a review!