BBB Logo

Better Business Bureau ®
Start With Trust®
28 counties covering Western Pennsylvania
Are you the Owner of this Business? ×
BBB® Accredited Business Seal

Are You the Business Owner of Blair Corporation?

If yes, click here to login.

Are you...?

BBB Accredited Business since

Blair Corporation

Additional Locations

Phone: (800) 458-6057 Fax: (814) 726-6097 View Additional Phone Numbers 220 Hickory St, Warren, PA 16366 http://www.blair.com View Additional Web Addresses

BBB Business Reviews may not be reproduced for sales or promotional purposes.

Description

Orchard Brands is a multi-channel marketer of apparel and home products to consumers through the direct channels of catalog, Internet and retail. Orchard Brands’s collection of companies includes Appleseed's, Bedford Fair, Blair, Coward Shoes, Draper's & Damon's, Gold Violin, Haband, Intimate Appeal, LinenSource, Monterry Bay, Norm Thompson, Old Pueblo Traders, Sahalie, Solutions, Tog Shop, Willow Ridge and WinterSilks.

BBB Accreditation

A BBB Accredited Business since

BBB has determined that Blair Corporation meets BBB accreditation standards, which include a commitment to make a good faith effort to resolve any consumer complaints. BBB Accredited Businesses pay a fee for accreditation review/monitoring and for support of BBB services to the public.

BBB accreditation does not mean that the business' products or services have been evaluated or endorsed by BBB, or that BBB has made a determination as to the business' product quality or competency in performing services.

Reason for Rating

BBB rating is based on 16 factors. Get the details about the factors considered.

Factors that raised the rating for Blair Corporation include:

  • Length of time business has been operating.
  • Complaint volume filed with BBB for business of this size.
  • Response to 232 complaint(s) filed against business.
  • Resolution of complaint(s) filed against business.
  • BBB has sufficient background information on this business.


Customer Complaints Summary Read complaint details

232 complaints closed with BBB in last 3 years | 73 closed in last 12 months
Complaint Type Total Closed Complaints
Advertising/Sales Issues 31
Billing/Collection Issues 85
Delivery Issues 14
Guarantee/Warranty Issues 0
Problems with Product/Service 102
Total Closed Complaints 232

Additional Complaint Information

The BBB has received reports of customer dissatisfaction during the last three-year reporting period. Complaints on file with the BBB range from delays in receiving merchandise to problems with crediting accounts when the merchandise was returned. The company has responded to all complaints by either re-shipping the merchandise or crediting the customer’s account.

Additional Information

top
BBB file opened: October 01, 1972 Business started: 01/01/1910
Type of Entity

Limited Liability Company (LLC)

Business Management
Ms. Cathy Burnette, Customer Service Director Mr. Mike DelPrince, V.P. of Finance Ms. Cindy Dziendziel, Vice President Mr. Al Lopez, C.E.O. Ms. Kassy McComis, Billing Ms. Sandy Mineweaser, Customer Service Director Ms. Theresa Ruby, Vice President
Contact Information
Customer Contact: Ms. Cathy Burnette, Customer Service Director
Principal: Ms. Tracey L Morgan , Customer Service Director
Business Category

MAIL ORDER & CATALOG SHOPPING MENS CLOTHING & FURNISHINGS-RETAIL WOMENS APPAREL-RETAIL CLOTHING-RETAIL

Alternate Business Names
Appleseed's Bedford Fair Coward Shoes Gold Violin Gold Violin, Inc. Linen Source Norm Thompson Orchard Brands Inc Sahalie Solutions Tog Shop WinterSilks
Additional Information

Blair Corp has established its own bank to provide credit to customers. JLB Service Bank will provide unsecured credit cards to customers for shopping at Blair only.


Additional Locations

  • 100 Murray Dr

    Warren, PA 16368

  • 1000 Murray Drive

    Warren, PA 16368

  • 1911 Leesburg Rd.

    Grove City, PA 16368 (800) 458-6057

  • 220 Hickory St

    Warren, PA 16366 (800) 458-6057

  • 220 Hickory St

    Warren, PA 16366

  • 220 Hickory St

    Warren, PA 16366

  • THIS LOCATION IS NOT BBB ACCREDITED

    71 Dodge St

    Beverly, MA 01915

  • THIS LOCATION IS NOT BBB ACCREDITED

    PO Box 198

    Jessup, PA 18434

  • RD#2 Box 803

    ALTOONA, PA 16601 (814) 941-4949

  • 1
X

What is a BBB Business Review?

We offer free reviews on businesses that include background, licensing, consumer experience and other information such as governmental actions that is known to BBB. These reviews are provided for businesses that are BBB accredited and also for businesses that are not BBB accredited.

X

About BBB Business Review Content & Services:

Some Better Business Bureaus offer additional content & services in BBB Business Reviews.
The additional content & services are typically regional in nature or, in some cases, a new product or service that is being tested prior to a more general release.
Not all enhanced content & services are available at all Better Business Bureaus.

Professional AffiliationsX
X

Types of Complaints Handled by BBB

BBB handles the following types of complaints between businesses and their customers so long as they are not, or have not been, litigated:

  • Advertising or Sales
  • Billing or Collection
  • Problems with Products or Services
  • Delivery
  • Guarantee or Warranty

We do not handle workplace disputes, discrimination claims or claims about the quality of health or legal services.

X

BBB Complaint Process

Your complaint will be forwarded to the business within two business days. The business will be asked to respond within 14 days, and if a response is not received, a second request will be made. You will be notified of the business's response when we receive it (or notified that we received no response). Complaints are usually closed within 30 business days.

X

What is BBB Advertising Review?

BBB promotes truth in advertising by contacting advertisers whose claims conflict with the BBB Code of Advertising. These claims come to our attention from our internal review of advertising, consumer complaints and competitor challenges. BBB asks advertisers to prove their claims, change ads to make offers more clear to consumers, and remove misleading or deceptive statements.

X

What government actions does BBB report on?

BBB reports on known significant government actions involving business' marketplace conduct.

X

Thank you for your feedback!

Help us improve by taking our survey.

X

BBB Reporting Policy

As a matter of policy, BBB does not endorse any product, service or business.

BBB Business Reviews are provided solely to assist you in exercising your own best judgment. Information in this BBB Business Review is believed reliable but not guaranteed as to accuracy.

BBB business Reviews generally cover a three-year reporting period. BBB Business Reviews are subject to change at any time.

X

Additional Phone Numbers

  • (800) 458-2000(Phone)
  • (800) 458-4438(Phone)
  • (814) 723-3600(Phone)
  • (814) 726-6009(Phone)
  • (814) 726-6021(Phone)
  • (814) 726-6028(Phone)
  • (814) 726-6376(Phone)
  • (814) 728-8140(Phone)
  • (866) 330-0541(Phone)
  • (877) 392-7099(Phone)
  • (814) 437-4790 (Fax)
  • (814) 726-6466 (Fax)
Find a LocationX

  Change Location
Show Only Accredited Locations


Complaint Detail(s)

8/26/2014 Billing/Collection Issues
8/25/2014 Problems with Product/Service
8/22/2014 Problems with Product/Service
8/12/2014 Billing/Collection Issues
8/11/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I am not a regular Appleseed's customer. I made an online purchase on January 16/17 2014 with a seldom used credit card and (apparently) "signed up" for a VIP membership. I have absolutely no recollection of signing up for this - it would not have interested me as I am not a regular shopper.Because the credit card is seldom used, I don't examine the statement closely on a regular basis. Today, I noticed that I was charged $1.99 on January 16, 2014, and, then, beginning on February 15, 2014, have been charged $14.97 every month for this membership. I have been charged $14.97 six times - Feb - July. I called Customer Service today to find out what the charge was for and was informed that I signed up for the program. I was told that they would cancel my membership, effective today and that I would not be charged for any additional months. When I requested a refund of all of the charges to date, the representative said she could refund 1 month. I next mentioned that I would file a dispute with my credit card company, and she then checked with her manager and said that she was authorized to refund the past 90 days charges (I'm not sure if that means 3 month's charges of the $14.97). I'm not sure how this membership is actually offered or advertised, but, it is obviously not apparent to the consumer that you are signing up for it. (I still question that I actually did sign up for it).

Desired Settlement: Refund of all charges - $14.97 x 6 and $1.99. total of $91.81

Business Response:

On August 7, 2014 we called Ms. ****** and left a message to explain that after she made her January 14, 2014 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Appleseed’s purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Appleseed’s VIP Plus program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Appleseed’s purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.


To enroll in this program, she clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Appleseed’s VIP Plus. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking the “Join Now,” she activated a membership in Appleseed’s VIP Plus.   Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.


As requested, Ms. ******’s membership in Appleseed’s VIP Plus was canceled on August 6, 2014.  On August 6, 2014 we issued three credits of $14.97 each (3 x $14.97) to the credit card for a total of $44.91.  On August 7, 2014 we issued an additional three credits of $14.97 each plus one credit of $1.99 (3 x $14.97 + $1.99) to the credit card for a total of $46.90.  A full refund of $91.81 has been issued to Ms. ******’s credit card. 

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

Sincerely,

 

****** ********

Assistant Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID ********, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

8/4/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I recently ordered a product from the company Linen Source. After receiving the product I noticed that it was damaged so I contacted the customer service. Instead of replacing the product I decided I would just like to return the product and receive the total refund of the product. The cost of the product was $195.95 + $19.99 for shipping which appeared on my bank statement on 7/1/2014. Since the product was damaged in the mail, the customer service representative insisted that I keep the product and not return it because it was damaged. They also told me that they would refund the total price of the product plus the shipping within 48 hours which would total $205.94. Instead they shipped another product and charged my account again of $165.96 on 7/16/2014 again without my authorization. I called again and spoke with a supervisor, Mr. *******, where he said they would credit my account once again and cancel the order. The following day I received a second product in the mail. I called again and Linen Source credited me $185.95 on 7/15/2014. After talking to him I notified him that I would report his business and he told me to do whatever I needed to do and hung up on me. After all of these events took place I am still owed $185.95.

Desired Settlement: I would like to have the rest of my money owed to me to be put back into my account. The total amount owed from Linen Source is $185.95.

Business Response:

We received a call from his fiancé, ******* ******, this morning regarding this matter. We assured her that the credit for $185.95 went through our system on 07/16/14. Mr. ******** was in the room with her at the time, and he verified with his bank online that the credit was there. We also explained to Ms. ****** that there was no need to return the exchange order that was shipped to her in error.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

***** ** ******Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/1/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I placed an order with this company and have been charged an extra $14.97 for the last 2 months. They say it is for a discount plan that I don't believe, I authorized. I believe they understand most of thier customers are old and easy targets for charging extra costs. Will not utilize their services again.

Desired Settlement: Mostly to warn others of thier practices.

Business Response:

On July 17, 2014 we called Ms. ******* and explained that after she made her April 30, 2014 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Gold Violin purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Gold Violin VIP Plus program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Gold Violin purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, she clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Gold Violin VIP Plus. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking the “Join Now,” she activated a membership in Gold Violin VIP Plus.   Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

 

As requested, we cancelled Ms. ********* Gold Violin VIP Plus membership on July 16, 2014 and issued two credits of $14.97 and one credit of $1.99 to her credit card.  Ms. ******* has been fully refunded in the amount of $31.93.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

****** ********

Assistant Compliance Coordinator 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

7/25/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Blair is falsely advertising items they do not have but are back ordered and they do not disclose this fact so consumer can make an informed decision to submit order or shop elsewhere. They are charging credit card for full amount of purchase, not processing and shipping out items right away, and lying about the fact that order is in shipping. They refuse to cancel order and credit the full amount back to card and continue to lie about the status of order. Four days have passed and my order has not shipped. Four days and my money is not accessible to me. I could have chosen to shop at another company online if I was not so deceptively mislead about the facts. Rather than cancelling my order and not charging my **** when infact Blair could have since my order had not been processed or in shipping, but lied about to continue to mislead me. Not only are these unfair business practices for other companies who could have got my business, it is fraudulent and misleading advertising about available items when they are not available and charging a credit card when items will not be shipped out. This way they can attempt to retrieve the shipping cost when the order is refused. There is a criminal win for Blair and a costly loss for consumer with these types of deceptive business practices. Not to mention that the consumer's money is not accessible to him/her for several weeks.

Desired Settlement: Full refund of $24.95 immediately. Right Now!

Business Response:

Thank you for forwarding the complaint to us from ***** ***.

 

Our records indicate Ms. *** attempted to have her order cancelled on July 17, 2014. Her order was too far along in processing for us to cancel at that time. Her order was shipped on July 18, 2014 with Fedex smartpost tracking number **********************. Her order shipped complete with no items on backorder. Our standard shipping time is 4-8 business days. We have waived the return label fee if the customer would like to return her order for a full refund.

 

Your assistance in resolving this matter for Ms. *** is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

****** *******
Customer Service Specialist

Consumer Response:

Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID ********, and yes, I certainly do want a full refund.  The package will be picked up by USPS July 25, 2014 and returned to Blair.  As far as Blair's response regarding package shipped on July 18, 2014, the message I received from Blair on July 18 does not state my order has shipped.  All that message states is "package will ship soon" with no definite shipping date.  Blair is the only company that charges credit card 4  days before shipping order, does not provide a shipping confirmation message to inform customer that package has shipped, and provides a return prepaid label for $9.99.  All other mail order companies I purchase from charge anywhere from $5.95 to $7.95 for their return shipping.  I firmly believe these are deceptive business practices by Blair, and I am without $24.95 of my money since July 15, 2014.  Who knows when Blair will decide to credit my account.  The consumer should know about, and be aware of how this company operates so they can make a fully informed choice about whether to purchase from company or not. 

Regards,

 

***** ***

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

7/16/2014 Billing/Collection Issues
7/14/2014 Problems with Product/Service
7/9/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I had tentatively ordered an item online 6-8 weeks ago, but the item was on an indefinite back order so I cancelled the order. Yesterday the company withdrew payment from my debit/checking account which overdrew my account. They had never notified me regarding this order to verify if I was still interested or that the item was now available if I was still interested. The item has not shipped but they can do nothing to stop it, now I have to wait for the item to be delivered then return the item and wait for my refund. Meanwhile I have incurred overdraft charges besides an unauthorized withdrawal. I am not sure what their policy regarding cancelled or backorder items is because I couldn't get a straight answer. But I do know the had my email address and I should have been contacted. The order number is ********, I didn't have this info because I cancelled the order but when I called to make my complaint this is the number they gave me.

Desired Settlement: I want a refund

Business Response:

On 06/20/14, copies of Ms. ***’s chat to customer service and a write-up of her telephone call to cus***er service were forwarded to our office. We issued a credit of $58.46 to her credit card on 06/20/14, and it went through our system on 06/23/14. The funds should be in her account in approximately three business days. We sent her an email the same day, and we have attached a copy of the email along with her response. If her bank is unwilling to reverse the overdraft charges, they should fax a copy of the charges to my attention at ###-###-####.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ** ******Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

Orchard Brands

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

7/9/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: When purchasing online you are signed up for "Blair Rewards Program" without the information about this program being fully disclosed. When talking with the company rep I was told that had being ongoing since Oct. 2012.

Desired Settlement: Refund for the accrued amount.

Business Response:

            Thank you for forwarding the above referenced complaint.

           

On June 23, 2014 we called Ms. ****** and left a message to explain that after she made her October 2, 2012 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Blair purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Blair Rewards program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, Ms. ****** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Blair Rewards. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, Ms. ****** activated a membership in Blair Rewards.   Had Ms. ****** skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

 

As requested, we canceled Ms. ******’s Blair Rewards membership on June 19th and issued one credit of $14.95 to her credit card. On June 23rd, we issued eleven credits of $14.95 each   (11 x $14.95) to her credit card and eight credits of $14.95 each plus one credit of $1.95            (8 x $14.95 + $1.95) via a refund check. Ms. ****** has been fully refunded in the amount of $300.95.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

Sincerely,

  

***** ************** Coordinator           

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

6/27/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I received an email offering free shipping to complete my order with the items in my bag. Those items were promotionally priced so that if you purchased 2 or more, there was a per-item discount, no promotion code needed. The free shipping code in my email did not work so I contacted Customer Service. They said I could not use it with any other promotions, even though the email itself said there were no minimums or restrictions and it showed the items that were in my bag -- which were priced on promotion. Here is the wording from the original email:Get free shipping with no minimum on items left in your bag. Having trouble? View in web browser Free Shipping - No MinimumLike Us On FacebookNew ArrivalsApparelAccessoriesShoesMonterey BaySale and OutletYour online shopping bag is set to expire.Place your order today & receiveFREE SHIPPINGon your entire order.Enter Promo Code ******** ** Redeem.Click Here for the New ArrivalsITEMS CURRENTLY IN YOUR SHOPPING BAGSleeveless ****** ************ *********** **** ******** **** Free Shipping on Standard Shipping only. Please add *************************** to your address book. UNSUBSCRIBE PRIVACY POLICY | CONTACT US | CUSTOMER SERVICE 2012 Appleseed's Inc. 30 Tozer Road, Beverly, MA 01915

Desired Settlement: I would like BBB to flag that Appleseeds does not honor its advertised offers. This email and their refusal to honor the free shipping they offered for items in my bag seems like a violation of the truth in advertising laws. They have permanently lost me as a customer.

Business Response: Thank you for contacting our office in regard to Ms. *****'s complaint and providing us with the opportunity to resolve. 

 
in reviewing our files we find we find that we have not received a recent order from Ms. *****. If she was attempting to place an online order it was not submitted for processing. Apparently she contacted our Customer Service regarding an online promotion of free shipping and also a pricing discount for ordering two or more tops. Unfortunately, she was provided with misinformation and was advised she could not take advantage of both offers. We apologize that she was provided with incorrect information and cancelled her order before submitting it. Our company does have a policy to only be able to apply one promotional offer per order. However, the offer that 
Ms. ***** was attempting to take advantage of was a discount for purchasing two or more of the same item and this is not considered a promotional offer such as free shipping or a coupon offer for money off. 
 
We are taking the necessary steps to prevent this from happening in the future. We sincerely apologize for the misunderstanding and inconvenience caused.
 
We hope this will resolve the matter for Ms. *****. If we can be of further assistance, please don't hesitate to contact our office.
 
Sincerely,
 
 
**** ******* Customer Service Specialist

Consumer Response:

Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID ********, and have determined that this does not resolve my complaint.  For your reference, details of the offer I reviewed appear below.

Appleseeds' response fails to address my complaint:

1. I received an email offer of free shipping if I would COMPLETE THE ORDER within the next 24 hours for the items that were sitting in my bag. I clicked the link in the email about 8 hours after it was sent to me, well within the 24-hour window. 

2. The email offered free shipping for the items currently in my bag -- and it listed 2 of the items in my bag. Those items were on a promotion for a lower price when buying 2 or more. 

3. The offer explicitly stated "no minimum purchase" and it contained NO LANGUAGE about any exclusions. 

4. I attempted to place the order and get the offered free shipping by typing in the code provided in the offer email. After typing in the code for free shipping, I got a popup screen that said this code was invalid.

5. After getting the "invalid code" popup screen, I contacted Customer Service via their email form.

6. Customer Service replied via email stating I could place the order; then call Customer Service for free shipping PROVIDED MY BAG CONTAINED NO PROMOTIONS. This directly contradicted the offer email.

7. I replied via email to Customer Service clarifying what the offer said and in fact copied and pasted their original offer so they could see the wording.

8. I received two completely off-the-mark replies from Zachary in Customer Service telling me there was a semantic difference between "sale" items and "promotional" items. He failed to address the fact that the original offer email contained no language prohibiting free shipping if the bag contained items on promotion or sale. Furthermore, he did not bother to clarify whether the items in my bag were "sale" or "promotion" even though Appleseeds clearly had access to my bag, since they showed two of those items in the original offer email. 

9. At no time did Customer Service attempt to engage me or clarify the matter by asking further questions about what was in my bag. They simply assumed I was in the wrong and they completely failed to address the language in the original offer email, which contained no exclusions for free shipping if I would purchase the contents in my bag in 24 hours, no minimum purchase required and no stated exclusions. That email listed 2 of the items in my bag -- so clearly, Appleseeds was able to view what I was planning to purchase. 

10. If Appleseeds did not want to offer free shipping as an incentive to complete my purchase in 24 hours, then it should either (1) NOT have sent the email at all or (2) explicitly and clearly stated in the offer email that the free shipping offer did not apply to promotional and sale items -- or that it would allow either the free shipping or no promotional pricing, one or the other -- not both. 

11. The response from Appleseeds to BBB is similar in tone to the responses from Customer Service to me via email. They failed to acknowledge the wording of the original email. As a result, they have lost me as a customer. How difficult would it have been to allow free shipping? 

12. I maintain that Appleseeds fraudulently advertised free shipping when in fact they had no intention of offering this. The offer email should have been clear about the exclusions -- and since it was not clear, then Appleseeds Customer Service should have honored the free shipping as a gesture of goodwill and acknowledgment that their offer email was misleading. Instead, they continue to state that I am in the wrong. 

Wow. Way to build customer loyalty.

Regards,

**** *****

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: After reviewing the position of all parties, BBB determined that the business made a reasonable offer to resolve the complaint. However the consumer did not accept the offer.

6/23/2014 Problems with Product/Service
6/17/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I ordered two pair of pants for my husband. Upon further review, I noticed that they had my address incorrect.I called them to correct this and got a total array of negative attitudes about changing it. I decided based on this encounter to cancel my order altogether. The order was still in processing and had not been charged. No one cancelled it, and it still was charged and sent. The dateline from the original order on May 19,2014 until still in processing on May 22,2014 was plenty of time to cancel it and not charge my account, even per paypal agreed.

Desired Settlement: i want a full refund

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from **** ***** **********

 

We have issued full credit on 6/2/14 to Ms. *********’s Paypal account for the order we were unable to cancel. When the customer contacted us to cancel the order, it was too far along in processing. The tracking on the order is showing it is on the way back to us. Credit was issued for $49.98.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

****** *******
Customer Service Specialist

Office of the President

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

6/11/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I ordered a skirt from Blair and when I received it I did not care for it so I sent it back with the return label that was sent to me with the merchandise. The price of the skirt was $29.99 and shipping cost was $9.99 Total $39.98. I emailed customer service to ask when my credit card would have the credit on it and was told that I would only be getting $20 credit. Blair charged me another shipping charge for the return. This product cost me $19.98 in shipping. I should not be paying for two shipping charges when Blair sent the return label to me with my merchandise. Hopefully, this issue can be resolved and I will get the second shipping charge as a credit on my card.Thank you for your time regarding this complaint

Desired Settlement: That the second shipping charge of $9.99 show as a credit on my card

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ****** *****.

 

The original charge for the order was $39.98 for the skirt (29.99) plus shipping and processing (9.99). Shipping and processing is not credited when merchandise is returned. When Ms. ***** returned the skirt, a credit of $20.00 was issued on 06/03/14 for the return of the skirt (29.99) minus the return label fee (-9.99).

 

The fee is shown on the front of the label, and an explanation of the fee is shown on the back of the packing slip. She was under no obligation to use the label. Merchandise can be returned by using the delivery method of her choice. We have attached copies of both sides of our packing slip and our return policy.

 

Due to the misunderstanding, an additional credit of $19.98 is being processed for both the shipping and processing charges and the return label fee.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 ***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

 

 

Consumer Response: Good evening

Regarding my complaint #******** - I made a copy of the mailing label and did not see - in small print - that indeed the cost of using the label would be $9.99 so that being said I would like to drop the complaint against Blair.

Thank you for time regarding this complaint.

Regards

****** *****

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

6/4/2014 Problems with Product/Service
6/4/2014 Problems with Product/Service
6/2/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I had ordered some clothing & was charged $72.97, the problem is that when you send back the items to them by using the pre paid postage they take off $9.99. I was only given credit for $49.99 which is incorrect & it should be $62.98.

Desired Settlement: I want the $12.99 that is still owed to me

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ***** *******

 

The original charge for order # ******** was $72.97 for a Navy Floral Casual Dress (29.99), Blue Jacket Dress (29.99), plus shipping and processing (12.99). A credit of $49.99 was issued on 05/29/14 for the two products she returned (59.98) less the return label fee (-9.99). The original shipping and processing charges are not refunded when merchandise is returned.

 

In the interest of customer satisfaction, we are processing a credit of $22.98 to Visa for both the original shipping and processing charges and the return label fee.

 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter for Ms. ****** is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ** ******Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

 

 

 

 

 

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID ********, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

5/20/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I have just discovered unauthorized charges of $14.95 per month going back 3+ years. I supposedly enrolled in a rewards program when I ordered something in Jan 2011. (I definitely will be watching statements more closely.) I see numerous complaints about this practice with Norm Thompson going back for YEARS. I did contact them today using the phone number on my credit card statement to drop the service I did not request, and was initially offered a refund of 2 months' charges. After further discussion, representative offered 4 months but refused anything more. I have also contacted my credit card company to ensure no more charges will be accepted, and they have opened a dispute for fraudulent charges. I have also contacted Norm Thompson customer service via email and requested a full refund of the charges.

Desired Settlement: Refund of 40 months of monthly charges totaling $598.

Business Response:

Thank you for forwarding the above referenced complaint.

On May 2, 2014 we emailed Ms. **** to explain that after she placed her April 1, 2011 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15.00 off her next Norm Thompson purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Norm Thompson Rewards program. There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Norm Thompson purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

To enroll in this program, Ms. **** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Norm Thompson Rewards. By entering her email address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, Ms. **** activated a membership in Norm Thompson Rewards. Had Ms. **** skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

Per Ms. ****’s request, we canceled her Norm Thompson Rewards membership on May 1, 2014 and issued twelve credits of $14.95 each (12 X $14.95) to her credit card and twenty-five credits of $14.95 each plus one credit of $1.95 (25 X $14.95 + $1.95) via refund checks. Ms. **** has been fully refunded in the amount of $555.10.

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

Sincerely,

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

Hi, I wanted to provide you with an update regarding my complaint against Norm Thompson’s Reward program.  I have received a full refund from them this week. J

 

Thank you very much,

 

**** ****

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

5/6/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: On April 4, 2014 I ordered 2 flutter tees ivory large. When they arrived, they were not silk but some sort of synthetic fabric so they were returned. The cost was $88.97 . The order number is ********. Now they claim they did not receive it when someone at their end stole the blouses and refuses to give me a refund. The first fraud was advertising silk fabrics that were a fake synthetic fabric called modal. Then they refused to refund the purchase price and mailing. That is fraud and people need to be warned about how badly Wintersilks.blair.com treats their loyal customers and robs them.

Desired Settlement: I want a refund of $88.97 for the two fake silk blouses that were returned in good faith only to be stolen at their end. If they are so hard off they have to rob loyal customers who have been customers for many years, then they need to shut down.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from **** ******.

 

We telephoned Ms. ****** on 04/29/14 to explain that it normally takes 10 to 14 business days from the date of the return for credits and/or exchanges to be processed.  Credits for $75.98 and $12.99 are being processed for the returned merchandise and the shipping and processing charges. The credits should be in her account by the end of this week or early next week.

 

We have attached a printout from our website showing that the product is advertised as “Modal” and not “Silk”.

 

Modal® is a man-made regenerated fiber. British generic fiber category for manufactured fiber of cellulose known for chemical, moth, and mildew resistance. Also recognized for heat and/or burn resistance. Modal® is a bio-based fiber made by spinning reconstituted cellulose from beech trees. It is about 50% more hygroscopic, or water-absorbent, per unit volume than cotton is. It is designed to dye just like cotton, and is color-fast when washed in warm water.

 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter for Ms. ****** is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ** ******Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

Consumer Response:

Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID ********, and have determined that this does not resolve my complaint.  For your reference, details of the offer I reviewed appear below.

[To assist us in bringing this matter to a close, we would like to know your view on the matter.]

Regards,

**** ******

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: After reviewing the position of all parties, BBB determined that the business made a reasonable offer to resolve the complaint. However the consumer did not accept the offer.

5/1/2014 Problems with Product/Service
4/23/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: On March 1st, 2014, I placed an order, number ********, for a pair of size 14 slippers. A little over two weeks later I received a package with slippers inside. I tried them on. I must wear a size 14 because that is my foot size. This pair of slippers was not a size 14. They were so tight that I could not get my foot inside. Since 14 was the largest size that they offered, and these were not a size 14, I packaged up the slippers and used the Blair Return Merchandise label and gave it to my postal delivery person. I was charged $31.98 for this order. Blair only credited my ****** account $15.00. When I called Customer Service I was told that Blair deducted the $6.99 for their shipping and handling to me as well as $9.99 for using their return label. I am contending that the mistake was not mine. I ordered size 14. I got a much smaller size than 14. Either Blair mislabeled their product or their supplier did. I should not be charged for their mistake.

Desired Settlement: I want my remaining $16.98 refunded.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the above referenced complaint.

 

Due to the circumstances Mr. ******** described in the complaint, we agree that he should not be held responsible for the shipping and processing charges and the return label fee.  A credit of $16.98 is being processed, and the funds should be back in his account in the next 3 to 5 business days.

 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ** ******Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

4/10/2014 Billing/Collection Issues
4/8/2014 Billing/Collection Issues
4/8/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: The Blair Corporation charges $14.95 a month for nothing but the 'privledge' of holding a Blair Rewards card. This business practice is not clearly stated anywhere on their website. I called this company today, 4/2/2014 and was told that I was informed of the charge by mail. Evidently it is buried in the small print of some type of information that was supposedly mailed to my residence. I have never seen this data, I would never have agreed to such a practice had it been clearly presented to me at the onset.

Desired Settlement: In my opinion this company owes me $303.95, as this is the amount they have charged to my ******** card over the past 21 months. I did ask them for a refund today and was told they would refund $29.90, 2 months of charges for the 21 months they have taken.

Business Response:

After Ms. ********* made her June 3, 2012 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Blair purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Blair Rewards program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and Ms. *********’s purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, Ms. ********* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Blair Rewards. By entering her email address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, Ms. ********* activated a membership in Blair Rewards.  Had Ms. ********* skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

 

We canceled Ms. *********’ Rewards membership on April 2, 2014 and issued two credits of $14.95 each (2 x $14.95) to her credit card. On April 4, 2014 we issued ten credits of $14.95 each (10 x $14.95) to her credit card and nine credits of $14.95 each plus one credit of $1.95 (9 x $14.95 + $1.95) via a refund check. Ms. ********* has been totally refunded in the amount of $315.90.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.  I hope the Blair Corporation will be more precise when relaying information about the "Blair Rewards" card to those that sign up.

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

4/2/2014 Delivery Issues
3/28/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I had monthly chargesfor $14.95 on my credit card for something called Blair Rewards. Apparently I signed up for this when placing an order by hitting a continue button. I was not aware of this and they claim they sent me information which I am sure looked like normal junk mail. Did not even know what the Blair rewards offer and certainly never used any benfits. This went on for a year, as my husband thought this was a subscription issue, not realizing what it was. This has been for the past year for a total cost of $180, refund is for $59.I have seen other complaints for this and think this is a deceiptive practice. Upon my complaint after pushing the issue, I was only given a partial refund. Not happy and worry others could be getting hit with this. I think Blair needs to be forced on how they are presenting this to consumers.

Desired Settlement: I would like a full refund, and the practice changed so others are not able to accidently enroll in this.

Business Response:

After Ms. ****** made her February 20, 2013 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Blair purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Blair Rewards program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and Ms. ****** purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, Ms. ****** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Blair Rewards. By entering her email address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, Ms. ****** activated a membership in Blair Rewards.  Had Ms. ****** skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

 

We canceled Ms. ******* Rewards membership on March 5, 2014 and issued four credits of $14.95 each (4 x $14.95) to her credit card. On March 6, 2014 we issued eight credits of $14.95 each (8 x $14.95) to her credit card.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

3/18/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I found a 14.95 charge on my credit card bill from a purchase at Solutions catalogue When I called to complain the person I was talking to agreed to cancel the charge for this month and to give a refund for the past month. I did not knowingly sing up for this service. When I asked to speak with the supervisor I was told she was too busy.I keep getting apologizing e mails from customer service but they say they cannot handle this request. I think the company is being very dishonest and from reading other complaints, it seems the company has been doing this for quite some time.

Desired Settlement: I want a complete refund. I did not sign up for this service.

Business Response:

On March 17th we called Ms. ********* and left a message explaining that after she made her October 25, 2013 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Solutions purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Solutions VIP Plus program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Solutions purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, Ms. ********* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Solutions VIP Plus. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking on “Join Now,” Ms. ********* activated a membership in Solutions VIP Plus.   Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

 

We canceled Ms. *********’s Solutions VIP Plus membership on March 6, 2014 and issued four credits of $14.97 each (4 x $14.97) to her credit card. On March 10, 2014 we issued one credit of $1.99 (1 x $1.99) to her credit card. Ms. ********* has been fully refunded in the amount of $61.87.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.  Thank you for your help

Regards,

 

***** *********

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

3/17/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Misleading on FREE SHIPPING. Before Submitting my order on line, I chatted with their representative, she told me the Free Shipping would show at the end of my order once Submitted. I Submitted my order to see a link to get Free Shipping which was a link to JOIN Free Shipping for $83+, then you could cancel this club if you decided you did not want it. None of this was in the Advertisement or stated in the Chat. I find this misleading. I contacted the company within one hour of the order to cancel the order. They would not cancel this order and shipped it and charged me shipping fee, which were suppose to be FREE. I have talked to Support and they said nothing could be done. I find this to be false Advertising.

Desired Settlement: Credit my Credit card statement for the shipping charges without joining their club.

Business Response:

On March 14th we called Ms. **** and left a message explaining the free shipping offer was a promotion offered by Blair. When placing the order on-line she was to enter the promotional code in the space provided then click apply. If the promotional code is overlooked then the shipping and handling charge would be applied to the order. If the promotional code was entered, her order confirmation would show the shipping and handling charge was removed. We have since adjusted the shipping and handling charge of $11.99 and the balance of her order is $59.97.

 

We then explained to Ms. **** the shipping rebate offer on the order confirmation is a third party offer by **************** not a Blair offer and that by calling the **************** phone number listed (###-###-####) she was talking to a representative from **************** not a Blair representative. *** ************.com representative should have explained how their program works and describe the terms, benefits and cost of ****************.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

3/13/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Since July 21 2011 to Febr. 20 2014, Blair Rewards has been charging me $14.95 per month, for something that wasn't agreed upon! First billing was $1.95 July 21 2011, then increased the next month to $14.95 per month thru February 20 2014. Blair Rewards NEVER notified us in any manner, phone, email, mail etc, to tell us about tnis monthly charging program,that we never agreed to. Blair never gave us opportunity to stop these charges or keep us up to date with what was going on! ******** ****** Cards caught their scam and reported it to us. This was a Company that we did business with and trusted. Their action is very disappointing.This practice is totally unacceptable and maybe illegal. I demand all these fraudulant charges be refunded in full ASAP!

Desired Settlement: All the money that we paid for this Rewards program,in FULL. From July 21 2011 thru Februay 20 2014.

Business Response:

After Mrs. *** **** placed her order, she was presented with an opportunity to accept a membership in Blair Rewards for a full 30 days.  This offer included receiving, in the form of a gift code number, $20 off her next Blair purchase.  Mrs. *** **** was not obligated to accept the membership offer and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

The representative taking Mrs. *** ****** order was required to inform Mrs.*** **** of the program terms before asking her if she would like to accept it.  Any customer who is interested in the offer is asked to enter the last four digits of their telephone number on their telephone key pad to confirm their acceptance.  It is explained to the customer that after the first 30 days, the membership will automatically continue for a membership fee of $14.95 per month, billed by us as Blair Rewards to the same credit card, unless you asked to be canceled from the program.  Cancellation may be made at any time with no further obligation. 

 

Mrs. *** ****** Blair Rewards membership was canceled on February 21, 2014 and two credits of $14.95 each (2 x $14.95) were issued to her credit card. On February 24, 2014 ten credits of $14.95 each (10 x $14.95) were issued to Mrs* *** ****** credit card and nineteen credits of $14.95 each and one credit of $1.95 (19 x $14.95 + $1.95) were issued via refund checks.

 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

3/12/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I was falsey sold and charged for a product called "Blair VIP Plus". I am 93 years old. My son noticed that a bill contained this charge. I was told I ordered it on the phone. I did not. I feel they took advantage of the elderly. I don't order that often. Why would I order a program that charges me a monthly fee. I am on a fixed income. Please look into this and protect the elderly from this practice. After calling the company and talking to a very rude person who at first told me that she couldn't reverse the charge, my son took over and when he demanded to talk with a supervisor the agent then canceled the bogus service and reversed the charge. Other elderly people may not be so lucky.Thank you.

Desired Settlement: Please alert the management and place a notice in your files and on your web about this practice.

Business Response:

On March 11th we emailed Ms. ******* to explain that after she placed her July 12, 2013 order, she was presented with an opportunity to accept a membership in Blair VIP Plus for a full 30 days.  This offer included receiving, in the form of a gift code number, $15 off her next Blair purchase.  Ms. ******* was not obligated to accept the membership offer and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

The representative taking Ms. *******’s order was required to inform Ms. ******* of the program terms before asking her if she would like to accept it.  Any customer who is interested in the offer is asked to enter the last four digits of their telephone number on their telephone key pad to confirm their acceptance.  It is explained to the customer that after the first 30 days, the membership will automatically continue for a membership fee of $14.97 per month, billed by us as Blair VIP Plus to the same credit card, unless you asked to be canceled from the program.  Cancellation may be made at any time with no further obligation. 

 

As requested, Ms. *******’s Blair VIP Plus membership was canceled on March 8th and one credit of $14.97 (1 x $14.97) was issued to her credit card. On March 10th we issued six credits of $14.97 each plus one credit of $1.99 (6 x $14.97 + $1.99) to her credit card.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is the best that can be done under the circumstance.   The practice of of selling a "non value" product to unsuspecting elderly should be discontinued.  It is clear that this hard sell tactic is pushed by the company.  I called to purchase a clothing item only.  

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

3/4/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: In placing an online order with Wintersilks in December, a popup came up asking if i wanted to be a VIP member. I responded yes and proceeded with my order. I have recently received my credit card bill with a charge from Wintersilks VIP Plus for $14.97 on Jan 11, 2014. Then i noticed a charge on my December credit card statement of $1.99. I did receive a package in the mail in late January describing this program but could not find any mention of a monthly charge. If it is there, it is well hidden. I called Wintersilks VIP Plus at ###-###-#### inquiring about these charges in which they described these as monthly charges for membership. The representative took the Feb charge (i have not even gotten this credit card statement yet) off of my credit card bill and closed my account. I asked who i could escalate this issue to and was given the main Wintersilks # of ###-###-#### which is basically the # to place an order. I was not aware of a billing for this service and still can find no mention of it in the packet i received. Note: i have attached the first two pages of the terms and conditions but could not figure how to attach the rest. As a regular customer of Wintersilks for over 15 years, I am stunned by this discovery. When i got the pop up screen in the middle of placing an order, I did not see any mention of charges. In addition, when i received the packet, it has cumbersome forms that must be manually filled out to receive any of the benefits they advertised which they failed to mention in the pop up screen. In addition, the Wintersilks rep mentioned that apparently there was a $15 gift card that i never received that was supposed to accompany this membership. I do not want to pay the $14.97 (Jan) and $1.99 (Dec) for a service I have not used and where the charges were not clearly disclosed.

Desired Settlement: Please refund $14.97 (billed to my credit card on 1/11/2014) and $1.99 (billed to my credit card on 12/12/2013). Please ensure there are no future billings for this program.

Business Response:

On March 3rd we called Ms. ******** to explain that after she placed her December 12, 2013 order on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next WinterSilks purchase, simply for trying a membership in our WinterSilks VIP Plus program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her WinterSilks purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, Ms. ******** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of WinterSilks VIP Plus. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking on “Join Now,” Ms. ******** activated a membership in WinterSilks VIP Plus.   Had Ms. ******** skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.  It was also explained to Ms. ******** that the cost is noted in the letter found in the Welcome Packet that contains the gift code as well as her username and password.

 

As requested, a full refund of $31.93 (2 x $14.97 + $1.99) was issued to Ms. Gundling’s credit card, and as a courtesy the $15.00 gift code was applied to order ******** which will show as a credit on her credit card statement.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: Wintersilks has resolved my issue (re:  complaint ID *******).  My thanks to the prompt service of the BBB for acting on my behalf.  They successfully contacted Wintersilks who then called me promptly and addressed ALL of my issues.   They were very courteous and proactive.    My thanks to BBB for your help.  

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

2/26/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: In December, made an order for my elderly mother and needed to receive quickly so used my credit card rather than mailing her check. Requested at time of order that I NOT receive any catalogs (required to give my name and mailing address due to credit card). Since then have received catalogs weekly. Have called 3 times, each time told that account is marked NOT to receive catalogs. When made first 2 calls, was told it could take up to 2 months to get name removed!!! after telling Blair at time of original order they were NOT to send them. Now has been 3 months and STILL receiving catalogs. Had previously told customer service reps to send complaint up the chain to corporate; today told customer service Laurel this and as well stated would make complaint to BBB. Am annoyed that my original request was ignored and that I continue to be harassed by receiving these catalogs, having to make multiple phone calls requesting Blair cease to send them and the waste of paper(=trees), mail services, etc.

Desired Settlement: Explanation of why I have received 3 months plus of catalogs after requesting at time of order NOT to receive them, description of how Blair will change their processes so this does NOT happen in the future, an apology for my inconvenience and waste of my time and a coupon for my mother in case we should ever decide to order something from Blair (in her name, by CHECK, of course!) in the future.

Business Response:

We are truly sorry that Ms. ****** was not placed on our Do not Mail list when she placed her mother’s order.  Her name has been removed from our mailing list, and we hope the catalogs will soon stop.  The last update on her customer file was 02/09/13 so we are unable to determine the exact date of the removal.  Our catalogs are printed in advance, and it normally takes up to three months from the date of the removal for the advertisements to stop.  If she receives more catalogs after the end of May, we recommend that she contact Customer Service and provide the information on the mailing label.

 As a gesture of goodwill and our sincerest apologies, we are sending ****** ****** a $25 gift card that can be used towards a future order.

 Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 Sincerely,

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

2/25/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I am a long time buyer of the following company Blair, I purchased two products from their catalog. I called the number to place the order and i was instructed to pay $50.00 Usd in order to receive both items. After they arrived I was told that I had a outstanding balance of $18.00 Usd. So without question I paid that amount. After a few months of that last payment I was contacted and told I owed about $132.00 Usd due to a miss payment of $2.00 Usd. I never received a letter or phone about my delinquent account. Now they want me to pay $214. Usd and have me in collections.

Desired Settlement: I want this off my record and I want to own nothing, I want them to show from what I owe $2.00 Usd from and if how they even managed to send that to collections without contacting me that I owed them that little amount.

Business Response:

******** ******* Bank owns and administrates our Blair credit card accounts. ******** ******* Bank will be responding to this complaint on our behalf.

 

Your assistance in the matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

****** *******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

2/25/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I DID NOT ORDER FROM THIS COMPANY BUT I DID ORDER FROM THEIR SISTER COMPANY.. NOW I AM GETTING CATALOGS FROM THIS COMPANY AND I AM TRYING TO GET ME OFF OF THEIR MAILING LIST... I HAVE GETTING MORE WHEN I AM SUPPOSE TO BE TAKEN OFF.. NOW THEY ARE TELLING ME LIES THAT I AM OFF... I TOLD THEM HOW DID THEY GET MY NAME WHEN I DID NOT DO NO ORDERING FROM THEM.. IT ALL CAME DOWN IT IS THAT THEIR SISTER CATALOG NAME OLD PUEBLO TRADERS GAVE THEM MY NAME..

Desired Settlement: JUST NOT TO GET NO MORE CATALOGS IN THE MAIL.. IN THE FUTURE NEVER GIVE OUT MY NAME TO ANY OTHER CATALOG....

Business Response:

Our records show that Ms. *******’s customer file was last updated on 01/17/14 for no catalogs from all Orchard Brands companies and no sharing of her information.  Our catalogs are printed in advance, so it may take up to two months for the removal to take full effect.  If she receives more catalogs after mid-April, we recommend that she contact Customer Service and provide the information on the mailing label.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

2/21/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I contacted the customer service and billing department regarding an discrepancy for Account *******************.I was concerned with the constant accumulation of charges although I have not recently made purchases. With the assistance of a customer service representative, it was discovered that I have been billed 14.95 monthly for almost 3 years for a rewards program thatI was unaware of and never requested to be enrolled. I requested to have the charge removed and credited back to my account because I have no idea what the program is or how to use it. I spoke with several representatives regarding adjusting my account but I was over talked and basically told that although I never added it, never used it, have no idea of how to use it, my account will not be adjusted. I have been a loyal customer and feel that the business practice of adding programs without acknowledgment is deceptive and dishonest. I feel that I have been taken advantage of.

Desired Settlement: I would like a full explanation and my account adjusted for the FULL amount of charges that were added to my account without acknowledgement.

Business Response:

On February 21st we called Ms. ****** to explain that after she placed her August 13, 2011 order, she was presented with an opportunity to accept a membership in Blair Rewards for a full 30 days.  This offer included receiving, in the form of a gift code number, $20 off her next Blair purchase.  Ms. ****** was not obligated to accept the membership offer and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

The representative taking Ms. ******’ order was required to inform Ms. ****** of the program terms before asking her if she would like to accept it.  Any customer who is interested in the offer is asked to enter the last four digits of their telephone number on their telephone key pad to confirm their acceptance.  It is explained to the customer that after the first 30 days, the membership will automatically continue for a membership fee of $14.95 per month, billed by us as Blair Rewards to the same credit card, unless you asked to be canceled from the program.  Cancellation may be made at any time with no further obligation. 

 

Per Ms. ******’ request, her membership was canceled on February 19, 2014 and a full credit was issued to her Blair credit card in the amount of $435.50.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.  

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

2/21/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: It has been over 1 yr that I have cancelled my Blair account. In the begining of Jan 2014 I received a letter from Blair Vip that I had a new charge of $11.94 for a purchase on Dec 3, 2013. I called on 1/20/14 to make Comenity Bank Vip Blair card aware the not only had I cancelled my account over a yr ago but I hadn't ordered anything from them. The lady told me that they would research this issue. I also called Blair's 800 number and their customer service told me to call the bank they use for accounts, which I already had. On the Jan 24th I received a letter stating that I would have to prove that this amount was charged to an alternative card in order for them to delete this non authorized charge from an account I no longer have. I want this issue cleared up. I haven't purchased nothing from Blair in over a year nor do I have a active Blair Account in over a year. The calls I make keep getting bounced back and forth from Blair corporation to the bank they use for customers.

Desired Settlement: Stop charging me for an order I didn't place on an account I no longer have.

Business Response:

Ms. ******* was billed $11.94 on her Blair Credit Card account due to an order processing error that was made.  The charge has been removed from her account, and the balance is now zero.  We called her and left a message on her voicemail to apologize and explain that the error has been corrected.  Her account is still open, and we recommended that she contact Comenity Capital Bank at ###-###-#### to close the account.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

2/21/2014 Delivery Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Complaint taken over the telephone by BBB staff (**).

 On November 9, 2013 consumer ordered a fleece jacket and paid $25.00. The jacket has not been delivered.
 Consumer has called the company several times and has left several voice messages with no response.

Desired Settlement: Delivery of fleece jacket or refund of $25.00

Business Response:

Her order has been on backorder since the order was placed on 11/11/13. We notified her by postcard through the US mail that her fleece jacket would be shipped by 2/5/14. Her fleece jacket was shipped on 2/4/14. A copy of the backorder notice being sent is enclosed and the tracking number for the package. It currently has a delivery date of 2/10/14. The order has not been noted that Ms. ******** has called in requesting this information.

 

Your assistance in the matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

****** *******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

2/21/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I sent back 3 pair of Capri knee shorts last year ,they hung in my closet for awhile I couldn't ware them they were to big in the waist. my sister told me to mail them back and get create last well I couldn't fine the return papers so I wrote every thing down on a piece of paper i ask for creit august 13th and I just found the receipt where I mail them back from the post office, and I call Blair and to see if they had go them .they said yes they said they send me a check for $14.cents I really down remember but she said Ms ***** FROM APPLESEED'S SHE TOLD AT ANOTHER TIME they didn't receivd them then she told me they smell bad and were dirty. I told ms ***** they were not dirth and smell I wouldn't send things back like that , then she said I didn't have the papers I told her I knew that but I copy down the numbers out of the catalog I had. I have been with blair a long time and satisfaction .she then said they could not find where I had ever order them. well I told her yes I did . If I didn't have the right papers and the knee shorts were dirty and smell why did they sent me a check they said for $14. cents I pay $65.00 for 3 pair .

Desired Settlement: I deserve to get the amount I pay for them so you take 14 and change off the 65.00 I deserve the money they didn't send the full amount for 3 pair.

Business Response:

The capris she returned were ordered prior to 2010, and we no longer have access to the original order.  In cases like this, a refund check is issued for the last known price of the item which was $4.99 each.  A refund check for $14.97 was sent to Ms. ****** on 08/20/13, and it was cashed on 09/04/13.  

 

We cannot refund the full price of merchandise no longer showing on our system without a copy of the packing slip that accompanies each order.  Merchandise should be returned in its original and unused condition.  Customer notes indicate the articles were not cleaned and the odor was so strong that the items had to be burned.  Due to these circumstances, we do not feel an additional refund is due to Ms. ******.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

 

Office of the President

Consumer Response:

when I sent these items back they were clean and had no odor ,the dirty items and the smell had to come from where they were sent to. If they smell so bad the lady at the post office would smell them and wouldn't send them . so the dirtness and smell was at their warehouse . I stand by my saying they were clean & no smell when I mail them back .I'M asking for what I pay for them more than $4.99 each I deserve a total of $ 35.dollars more .
 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: After reviewing the information provided by all parties, BBB determined that the business handled the matter appropriately, and no further action was needed.

2/20/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I originally called and asked to be taken off all their mailing lists on November 9th. It is now February 19th and I'm still receiving their junk mail. I have repeatedly called and keep getting the same, "I'll take you off our mailing list...You may receive a few more mailings as they are pre-printed" I've "Returned to Sender" a couple things and have a couple more to go back to them today too! It's been over three months!

Desired Settlement: I want OFF ALL THEIR mailing lists, ASAP!

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ***** ** ******.

 

Our records indicate that Ms. ****** was not completely removed from our mailing lists until 01/11/14, and we do apologize for that.  Our catalogs are printed in advance, and it normally takes approximately three months for the removals to take full effect.  If she continues to receive catalogs after mid-April of this year, we recommend that she contact customer service and provide the mailing label information on the back of the catalog.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

Consumer Response:

On several calls to Blair it was confirmed that I had originally called in November, NOT January as they are now stating! I feel this is just a delaying tactic by them. I want the mailings to stop NOW! They have had 3+ months to stop them and haven't. 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: After reviewing the position of all parties, BBB determined that the business made a reasonable offer to resolve the complaint. However the consumer did not accept the offer.

2/14/2014 Problems with Product/Service
2/13/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: My complaint is regarding the Blair Rewards program. It is a shame that this company took advantage of my mother who is 85 and has Alzheimer's. She has had $14.95 taken out of her checking account for almost two years because of this scam. I believe that the company should be made to reimburse her for this fraud. We have done business with Blair for many years, and I will not be purchasing anything further from a company who takes advantage of people like this. I was told that she agreed to the trial for $1.95 and then never called to cancel this. She could not have remembered to call and cancel this.

Desired Settlement: I would like to see a reimbursement for the money that was taken from her checking account.

Business Response:

On February 10th we called and left a message with Mrs. *******’s husband explaining that after his Mother-In-Law, Ms. ****** placed her August 5, 2012 order, Ms.****** was presented with an opportunity to accept a membership in Blair Rewards for a full 30 days.  This offer included receiving, in the form of a gift code number, $20 off her next Blair purchase.  Ms. ****** was not obligated to accept the membership offer and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

The representative taking Ms. ******’ order is required to inform all customers of the program terms before asking them if they would like to accept it.  Any customer who is interested in the offer is asked to enter the last four digits of their telephone number on their telephone key pad to confirm their acceptance.  It is explained to the customer that after the first 30 days, the membership will automatically continue for a membership fee of $14.95 per month, billed by us as Blair Rewards to the same credit card, unless you asked to be canceled from the program.  Cancellation may be made at any time with no further obligation. 

 

Per Mrs. ********* request, her mother’s membership was canceled on February 5th. On February 10th eleven credits of $14.95 each (11 x $14.95) were issued to her mother’s credit card and five credits of $14.95 each plus the trial period of $1.95 (5 x $14.95+$1.95) were issued via a refund check.

 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and have determined that this does not resolve my complaint.  For your reference, details of the offer I reviewed appear below.  My mother's credit cards have been cancelled because of her Alzheimer's Disease. So the credit should not be credited to a credit card because none exist.   If they do this where does the refund end up?  Will the credit card company send it to my mother???

Thank you.  


Regards,

**** *******

 

 

Business Response:

Our records show eleven credits of $14.95 each were issued back to the credit card used on the original order. This was a ****** **** ending in ****. The issuing bank is ***** ******* Bank, ATM & Card Operations, ** ******** ******* ********* ** *****. The phone number is ###-###-#### or ###-###-####. Below are the Acquired Reference Numbers for the eleven credits of $14.95 issued on February 11, 2014:

Mrs. ******* can call the bank with the above numbers and the bank will be able to confirm the credits of $11.95 were issued.  When contacting the bank, Mrs. ******* could request a refund from the bank. However the bank may have their own policies such as needing proof of Power Of Attorney before issuing any refunds.

 

Please feel free to contact us if we can be of further assistance to you.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

 

Regards,

 

 

**** *******

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

2/10/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I have contacted Blair numerous times to have my name removed from their database. Blair continues to send me unwanted junk mail.

Desired Settlement: Remove my name from Blair's database

Business Response:

We apologize for the inconvenience we have caused her.  The last update to her customer file was on 11/21/13.  Unfortunately, she was not correctly removed from our mailing list at that time.  Her customer file has now been properly marked for no mailings. However, our catalogs are printed in advance, and it may take up to three months for the removal to take full effect.

 

We are truly sorry that her request was not handled before now, but we want to assure her that the mailings will eventually stop.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

2/10/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: on this order, which placed with Customer Service employee, for one item @price of $17.99 with free shipping. Tax was questionnable at this time. I approved.When I received item and checked my bank account, debit for $19.52. I sent emails asking for this to be credited and debited for $17.99. Then I noticed their Order Summary showing Total as $19.52. I was not given Tax cost by this person.After calls and emails, I requested that someone straighten out the DEBIT amount and credit the difference of $1.53.After all this fooling around, Blair credited bank account with the amount of $10.53. Where they got that figure from not sure. I refused to deal with Blair any more. Therefore, I wish to file this Complaint, on my behalf, as I am sure other customers get the same treatment. $8.99 is a lot of money to me and others like me. What I want is for Blair to credit my account with 'additional funds' in the amount of $8.99.Thank you.

Desired Settlement: Statment above.

Business Response:

We apologize for any misunderstandings regarding her recent order.  We are required by law to collect taxes on orders from any state in which we have a business presence. Our system charges state sales tax based on individual state and county tax laws.  Ms. ******’s order total was $19.52 for the fleece tunic she ordered (17.99), plus sales tax (1.53).  Our order representatives are required to give the customer an order total after all products have been entered into our system.  If this information was not provided, we are truly sorry.

When Ms. ****** returned the merchandise, a credit of $10.53 was issued to **** for the tunic (17.99), sales tax (1.53), and minus the SmartPost return label fee (-8.99) when she chose to return the merchandise by using the label that was attached to the packing slip.  The fee for the label is shown on the front of the return label, and an explanation of the fee is shown on the back of the packing slip.  She was under no obligation to use the label. She had the option to return the merchandise on her own by using the delivery method of her choice.  We have attached copies of our packing slip and return policy.

Due to the misunderstanding, we are processing an additional credit of $8.99 to reimburse Ms. ****** for the return label fee.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

2/10/2014 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I have a major problem with a company your firm use to deal with and Im hoping you can help. The company is called easy saver. In 2008 my wife ordered some items from Sahalie and got free shipping by clicking on a button. Our credit card was charged $14.95 every month since 2008 for a total of $837. This was a company that a your firm was affiliated with and that is one reason I am upset. I was able to get them to refund $600. so I am still out more than $237. Im hoping you can make up the difference by issuing me a store credit. I called your customer support and they said they would pass it to corporate but I have not heard anything. I spoke with a Ms. *******. All Im looking for is the money I am out. I hope you help me with this issue. I have 4 girls and my wife and many friends who who at Sahalie and your other stores so I hope this works out. I would hate to have to tell them not shop at your stores.Thank you,**** *******

Desired Settlement: store credit for at least $237

Business Response:

On February 7th we called Mr. ******* and left a message explaining that after Mrs. ******* made her November 24, 2008 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Sahalie purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, Mrs. ******* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, Mrs. ******* activated a membership in Sahalie Rewards.   Had Mrs. ******* skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

 

As requested, we canceled the Sahalie Rewards membership and on December 31, 2013 we issued eight credits of $14.95 each (8 x $14.95) to Mrs. *******’s credit card and thirty-three credits of $14.95 each (33 x $14.95) via refund checks. On February 7, 2014 we issued fifteen credits of $14.95 each plus one credit of $1.95 (15 x $14.95 + $1.95) via refund checks.

 

We apologize for any misunderstanding, and hope this satisfies your concerns. We appreciate the opportunity to serve you.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

What I do find interesting is that when talking to customer support they indicated that the charges were from another company and they couldn't do anything about it. Thru BBB they state that it was their charges. 

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

1/31/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I discovered a recurring charge of $14.95/month on my credit card, which apparently has been charged monthly since 12/2012. I did order an item from the Solutions catalog in December 2012, but I would NEVER intentionally signup for a monthly charge, especially one that comes with no deliverable or benefit.When I spoke with representatives for the company they said that I had signed up for this program during the process of confirming my online order, but they would not or could not tell me what the program was to provide me, and there was never any confirmation, "welcome to the program," or other mention of this program made to me by Solutions. It only came to my attention when I saw the line-item charge on my credit card statement. I unfortunately overlooked this for a year, because of the relatively small amount billed each month and because it looked like any generic online order in the credit card statement. Both my wife and I order books, music, etc. online occasionally.If indeed there was some element of their online order form that mentioned this charge, it was not at all apparent to me. I believe this to be a scam, which I feel should be illegal. At best it is a deceptive and reprehensible business practice.In my conversation with the second Solutions representative I spoke with (supposedly a Manager), he offered a partial refund, but it became apparent to me that he was mainly focused on getting me to say some legally binding word, like "Yes," to a question like, "would you consider this (partial refund) to be a satisfactory resolution to this issue." I was careful not to give them any verbiage during our recorded conversation that could later get them of the hook for perpetrating this offense and, I believe, theft.

Desired Settlement: At the very least, a complete refund of all money charged to my credit card. At $14.95 times 13 months this comes out to $194.35.I also feel there should be penalties and compensation for my time and the personal offense of this matter. I will gladly join any class-action lawsuit against this company. They have cost me hours, already, trying to sort this out. We will have no credit cards for several days while we wait for new ones, and now we must update all vendors w/new CC#s.

Business Response: Please see the attached resolution. 

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID 9903220, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.  

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

1/21/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: On December 04,2013 I placed and order with Blair. It arrived approximately 10 days later. I returned 3 items the same day using the return label provided and the return item page. I have not been issued a refund on my items. I have made two inquiries by phone and one online request for my refund. Online I was told it would take approximately 7 days for the refund to show up on my credit account. On my first phone contact there was no refund that was processed. Today I contacted Blair customer service and was told it would take 2-3 weeks for the refund to be processed. I asked why it took so long and was given no reason. This is not acceptable to me.

Desired Settlement: Immediate refund applied to my account with not charge for return shipping. I also gave a free shipping code with return. Code number is *****

Business Response:

Her return of the sweater and two mock tops was processed in our returns department on 1/2/14 and credit processed to her ****** Account on 1/3/14 for a total of $49.97.

 

Your assistance in the matter is appreciated.

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

1/15/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Currently I examined my charge card charges carefully and found a charge called "NTO Solutions Reward" for $14.95 ocurring every month this year eleven times. I had no idea what the charges were for or how this organization got my card number. Upon further investigation I found that I had placed an order for an item from the Solutions catalog in December 2012 (which I received in perfect order) and was invited at that time (I am told) to join their "Rewards" program. Because I am on a fixed income, I am usually very careful not to "fall" for extra services/expenses...but apparently I did "fall" for this one. My complaint, after paying out over $164.45, is that I fear this "invitation" was not clear enough in its explanation of purpose and costs. I do not remember anything about it (although their customer service person explained its intent to me today) and as I do not travel or dine out often, it would not have been even considered by me.Thank you for checking into this for me (and others like me).

Desired Settlement: Careful investigation and refund if possible.

Business Response:

On January 14th we called Ms. ****** and left a message explaining that after she made her December 18, 2012 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Solutions purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Solutions Rewards program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Solutions purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

 

To enroll in this program, Ms. ****** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Solutions Rewards. By entering her email address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a membership in Solutions Rewards.   Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

 

Per Ms. *****’s request, we canceled her Solutions Rewards membership on January 14th and issued twelve credits of $14.95 each (12 x $14.95) for a total of $179.40 to her credit card.

 

We apologize for any misunderstanding, and hope this satisfies your concerns. We appreciate the opportunity to serve you.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

 

 

 

 

 

Consumer Response:

I consider their response very generous and swift.  Thanks you for your assistance in this matter.

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

1/14/2014 Billing/Collection Issues
1/9/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: on 10/15/13 I placed an order from Blair, in Warren Pa. ###-###-####. I received the items and returned them because they were too large. I asked for a refund of the cost, which I have not received ($61.98). A telephone call has been made three times about the status of the return, and was told various reasons and for me to call back in about a week.

Desired Settlement: It would be appreciated very much if you would see that the refund of $61.98 is refunded to me. This would be kindly appreciated.

Business Response:

We were able to reach her by telephone on 01/08/13, and she verified that she received the refund check for $52.99 on 01/07/13 and cashed it, although it was issued on 11/15/13.  We are sending her an additional refund check in the amount of $8.99 for the return label fee and we are also sending her a $25.00 gift card due to the inconvenience she has been caused.  She seemed pleased with the resolution.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

1/3/2014 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I purchased a Mens bandedbottom shirt from Blair. When it arrived , it was of inferior quality, the elastic band was loose & stretched out. I returned it for a refund & Blair charged me $8.99 for postage for the original order. I lost money returning the shirt using my own postage , nowthey want me to double pay for their postage too ! That's a rip-offorder # ********

Desired Settlement: $8.99

Business Response:

We apologize for any misunderstandings regarding our return policy.  The original shipping and processing charges are normally not credited when merchandise is returned.  However, the merchandise was apparently defective and we do not expect him to pay for those charges.  A credit of $8.99 is being processed, and once the credit is issued, the balance on his account will be $.00.  We left a message with his receptionist to explain that we will also gladly reimburse him for his return postage costs if he will tell us the amount, and we provided her with our telephone number.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

1/2/2014 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: i ordered shoes from Blair.com om 11/15/13.this order started off wrong they had the order on hold on the 12/18/13 stating my bank didn't approve the transaction. When i called the bank the rep stated they had tired to run the debit. finally on the 12/20/13 I received a email they had been shipped. the item was delivered on 11/27/13 and I returned them the same day because they sent the wrong size. on 12/10/13 I received an email stating they had credit$41.00 my account.but i paid $59.00 w/ shipping but this was not true on 12/14/13 the customer service rep stated she didn't see where there was a credit issued or pending for my account. But she did see where there was even exchange for the shoes .on 12/17/13 Blair go into my account a second time for the shoes that I don't have. Once again rep didn't see a credit issued and for me to wait several more days.now i'm left to pay the overdrafts causing other bills to returned for N.S. funds. After many conflicting conversations w/customer service and a anger letter to customer.i received a email from customer stating my credit was processed my Blair on Sunday 12/16/13.keep emailing me that they are sorry for charging me $8.99 to return a item that they shipped wrong to start, but not trying to correct the problem.

Desired Settlement: Refund my second payment of $49.99 and cover all overdrafts for returned checks totaling $105.00 because the mistake is made on their end . I shouldn't have to pay

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from Ms. *******.

 

We were able to reach her by telephone this morning, and she was kind enough to fax us a copy of the bank fees.  We are processing a credit of $105.00 to her account for the three overdraft fees inadvertently caused by her exchange order.  In addition to this credit, a credit of $41.00 was issued on 12/16/13 for the return less the return label fee, a credit of $8.99 was issued 12/18/13 for the return label fee, and a credit of $8.99 is being processing for the original shipping and processing charges.  We believe we have resolved the matter to Ms. *******’s satisfaction.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

12/30/2013 Delivery Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: i mailed in a order to blair it has been a whole month and i still have not received my merchandise it is all paid for.

Desired Settlement: I would like for the company to please send me my black fleeced jacket i really need my jacket,this jacket is just what i need for my wardrobe.i want them to send my jacket before christmas so i can start wearing it asap.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from Ms. *******.

 

Unfortunately the Black Fleece Jacket in size 2X is backordered until the end of January.  We called and left a message on Ms. *******’s voicemail.  She called us back, and she will be happy with the Denim Heather color.  We are express shipping the jacket at no extra charge, and she should receive the jacket before Christmas.

 

Your assistance in the matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.  

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

12/20/2013 Problems with Product/Service
12/19/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I have bought clothing products from Blair on numerous occasions, so was accustomed to seeing charges in my ******** ******* credit card bill. I only recently noticed that I was being charged $14.95 every month for "Blair Rewards." I called the telephone number given for "Blair Rewards" and was informed that because I had bought something for more than $50 I had automatically been signed-up for "Blair Rewards"-at a cost of $14.95 per month. This apparently took place three years ago!This is a total scam, as I was not aware that I was being signed-up for this program-which I would have rejected if I had been aware of it. The representative I spoke to could not tell me of a single benefit that I had gained from this membership. Meanwhile I have paid over $500 -for nothing! I have made my last purchase from Blair, and my attorney will be pursuing them for restitution.

Desired Settlement: Blair dishonestly signed me up for this program without proper notice of my options. I require full restitution of the money that they have illegally acquired from me, amounting to at least $538.20 - and possibly more.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your December 18th letter forwarding the complaint of ******* ******** ***, and we appreciate the opportunity to respond.

On December 18th we called Mr. *** and left a message explaining that when he placed his April 5, 2011 order on our website, he was presented with an opportunity to save $15.00 off his next Blair purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Blair Rewards program. There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and his Blair purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.

To enroll in this program, he clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and cost of Blair Rewards. By entering his email address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, he activated a membership in Blair Rewards. Had Mr. *** skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.

Per Mr.***** request, we canceled his Blair Rewards membership on December 18th and issued twelve credits of $14.95 each (12 x $14.95) to his credit card, twelve credits of $14.95 each (12 x $14.95) were issued via a refund check and eight credits of $14.95 each plus the trial period of $1.95 (8 x $14.95 + $1.95) were issued via a second refund check.

 As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of his complaint.

 Sincerely,

***** ****

Compliance Coordinator

 

 

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

I appreciate the willingness to refund the money I  had been charged as part of the "Rewards" program.  From online research I know that I am not the only one who has been inadvertently enrolled in this program,  I suggest that the enrollment process should be made a lot more transparent and easy for customers to understand.

Regards,

 

******* ***

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

12/18/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I've called Blair corporations subsidy Solutions.com on several occasions to remove my name from the mailing list and they still have yet to do so. Every time I've called they say the previous person I called never took me off the list which leads me to believe I am still on the list. After the woman was rude to me on the phone today I asked to speak to a manager in which she transferred me to a Spanish language extension which led to a voicemail. Obviously she had no intention of resolving the matter. The number I called ###-###-####, dates & times I've called: 11/29/2013 - 2:51pm 10/25/2013 - 7:16pm 06/08/2013 - 3:55pm Also, they have given(sold) my information to Signals.com. I called to have my name removed from their list but assume I will continue to deal with this headache.

Desired Settlement: A serious overhaul of their customer service department. Obviously this is not just one or two people causing this issue if there is no record of my inquiries or any explanation of why my information has not been removed. I am left to believe that many dissatisfied customers are experiencing the same problems as myself.I want my name and information to be removed from all of Blair Corporations mailing lists including all their subsidies. And an apology from the rude customer service.

Business Response:

We sincerely apologize to Mr. ****** for the inconvenience and frustration he has been caused.  He has now been removed from all mailing lists for all Orchard Brands companies.  Our catalogs are printed in advance, so it may take up to three months for the removals to take full effect. 

 We are also having his calls reviewed by a manager for quality assurance and to be sure the representatives he spoke with know the correct way to remove a customer from our mailing lists.  We updated our operating system in July, and there are two additional steps involved in removing a name which were apparently overlooked.

 For removal from most national advertising lists, he can also send his name, address, and request to:

****** ********* *********** **** ********** ******* ** *** *** ******* ** *****

 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter for Mr. ****** is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

12/2/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I called Norm Thompson to see why I was being charged $ 14.95, at the beginning of each month since February 4, 2012. My husband pays the bills and does not usually question my charges. When I called Norm Thompson's customer care department they stated it was for a rewards program I signed up for on the internet. This is entirely untrue, it is fraud. I never ever sign up for clubs, discounts, extra insurance, new credit cards etc. Customer service said they would stop charging me and remove the November 2,2013 charge. I protested, I explained I never signed up and I never received any of the benefits it was suppose to provide. I ask them to send me the proof that I signed up and they refused. I asked for a supervisor and *** * ******* said he was the supervisor. *** said they would call me in 24 business hours. Not good enough. I am contacting my credit card company to report the fraud. I think it might be prudent to report this fraud to the State Attorney General of Texas. Additionally I have found a number of complaints regarding this program on the internet. I will never shop at a Blair Company again.

Desired Settlement: I offered to settle for one half of the $328.90, requesting a refund of $165.00. They asked for a fair deal and that is what I offered. I now believe they owe me the full $328.90. I need a credit issued for $328.90 or it will be turned over to my attorney (sister).

Business Response: Response to Mrs. ******* complaint is attached.

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

12/2/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I used to have a Blair charge card. After my wife lost her job 3 years ago we went into financial distress and were forced to file bankruptcy. Prior to filing we tried to pay off everyone we could and Blair was one of the accounts we did pay off in full. After we filed they closed our account but, unknown to us they continued to bill us $14.95 a month for their special Blair rewards program which is a part of the account. It's my fault that I didn't catch this sooner (10 months)and we only found it because my wife applied for a new account and I saw the bill charged to my checking account. When I contacted them they basically said to bad even though they new the rewards program had no account tied to it. They did refund me 2 months but how many other poor souls are being bled slowly by this practice. The worst part is they offer this thing as get $15 off your next order but they don't tell you up front that the cost is 14.95 a month until you cancel! No one in their right mind would think that's a good deal.

Desired Settlement: Ultimately I would have like a refund for February thru September but I know they will show papers and emails confirming that buried somewhere deep inside an online order was my okay to pay them the $14.95! So just the fact that they now know a complaint has been filed against them.

Business Response: **** ***** ID ******* response attached.

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

Regards,

 **** *****

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

11/25/2013 Problems with Product/Service
11/25/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I ordered a raincoat and pair of shoes from their catalog 10 days before my departure for an overseas trip. I paid $38 for overnight delivery. The package was never delivered and no effort was made to contact me. I called a few days later to find out where the package was. They said a hold had been put on the order because the shipping and billing address were different. I asked why I hadn't been called or contacted. There was no answer. They promised to overnight it the next day and waive the additional charge for overnighting the package. It never arrived. I called again and they said oh- it'll be going out on Friday.. which means no one will be in the office to receive it AND I leave for my trip on Monday, crack of dawn. This has been an extremely frustrating experience and if I ran my company this way I'd be out of business so fast my head would spin.

Desired Settlement: Don't know what they can do at this point.

Business Response:

Thank you for forwarding the above referenced complaint.


We were unable to reach Ms. ********* by telephone to apologize for the delay in processing her order.  The order was held by our system due to the amount of the order and a ship to mismatch. We monitor these orders to protect our customers from possible fraud situations.


She placed her order on October 17th and the package was delivered on Friday, October 25th, at 2:56 pm.


If Ms. ********* was unable to pick-up her package on Friday before she left town, we sincerely apologize. We have credited the express shipping and standard shipping charges from her order. We have also waived the return label fee if she does not wish to keep the order.


Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter for Ms. ********* is appreciated.


Sincerely,




***** ****

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President


BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

11/13/2013 Problems with Product/Service
11/11/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I returned 2 shirts approx. 3 wks. ago because they were too big on me. When I received the refund check, it was $8.99 less than the check I had sent with my order. I called the customer service and they told me that since I used "their" return label, there was a charge/credit of $8.99. I asked if I had used a brown envelope and addressed it myself, would the charge be lifted; the rep told me that there would still be a charge but, maybe, not the $8.99. It would not have cost that much to mail it back; and, they always state "to your complete satisfaction" (underlined). I don't think it's right for them to charge for a return!

Desired Settlement: I would like the $8.99.

Business Response:

 

Thank you for forwarding the complaint you received from Ms. *****.

 

We apologize to her for any misunderstandings regarding our return policy. There is a fee of $8.99 for each use of the return label.  The fee is shown on the front of the label, and an explanation of the fee is shown on the back of the packing slip.  Our customers are under no obligation to use the label.  They can return merchandise on their own by using the delivery method of their choice.

 

In the interest of customer satisfaction, we are sending Ms. ***** a refund check for $8.99 to reimburse her for the return label fee, and we have attached a copy of our return policy and both sides of our packing slip.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.  I thank them for their "understanding".  This should be in bold print on the label, though.  The way it is, no one would think to read it; and, I just don't see why I should have to pay to return something that's not right.   Thank you for taking the time to deal with this matter.

Regards,

 

******** *****

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

11/7/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: On October 14th, I placed an order with Blair Company(###-###-####). I ordered eight items totaling $294.90 plus asked for prompt delivery. I was told by the customer service representative that it would take 2-3 days for delivery. My daughter was going on vacation, and since she did not have time to order her things, I asked the representative to deliver it to ** ***** ****** ** ********* *** ****. I called Blair on Friday and found out that the customer service representative put my things on "hold" and did not contact my credit card company. I was told by someone at ***** that it was never called in. I called Blair Company, put in a complaint and also asked to speak to a manager. The manager told me that sometimes they have to check the area that the merchandise is going. I told her she was taking up for her employee and I have never heard of such thing and I will be notifying the cooperation. This representative was spiteful and refused to place my order. My confirmation for this order is ********. When I checked their service it announced that I had cancelled the order and when I had placed my last order in December. I have never had any problem with any company in placing my order and sending it elsewhere.

Desired Settlement: I want Blair Company to know the type of person that they have working for them. This person cause you to lose a customer. I do not want anything, but she owe me an apology.

Business Response:

We were able to reach Ms. ******* by telephone to apologize for any misinformation she was given and also for not shipping the order that was to be sent to her daughter.  Unfortunately, we were unable to find the telephone call she referred to in her complaint.

 The order amount was $294.90, and it was approved by Ms. *******’s credit card bank on 10/14/13 when the order was processed.  However, the order was held by our system due to the amount of the order and a “ship to mismatch”.  We monitor these orders to protect our customers from possible fraud situations.  Normally these orders are released the next day if we determine they are legitimate.  For some reason, her order was still being held on 10/18/13 when she called to find out why her daughter had not received the order.  She canceled the order the same day.

 We sincerely apologize to Ms. ******* for the mishandling of her order, and we want her to know that this is not a typical example of the normally excellent services we provide to our customers.  We value each and every one of our customers, and we are truly sorry to lose her patronage.

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Office of the President

 

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

11/6/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: ***** *****, Downers Grove, IL placed an order October 10. My mother, also ***** ***** in Downers Grove, IL did not, however we are in Blair system, due to ordering from one of their other 13 stores. We received an order confirmation online for other ***** *****. I called promptly on October 10 to let them know they had wrong ***** ***** in Downers Grove, IL. They thanked me profusely and would of course correct the address. Then I received an email on October 18 that order had shipped so I replied back by email to let them know, they had wrong email address for other ***** *****. They replied and assured me they would correct. Saturday, October 19, I received shipment for other ***** ***** at my door. I promptly called Blair to let them know they had still not straightened out this mess. I gave package to my mailman the same day as they request so he could return to sender. In my mailbox that same day was a check for $10.00 made out to my mother, ***** *****, for overpayment of her order. I called Blair again, talked to a supervisor who was mortified about this whole mess and would clearly straighten this out. We were advised to rip up the check and they would reissue to correct ***** *****. Yesterday, November 2 I received a post card addressed to my mother, ***** *****, from Blair requesting more information to process the order obviously for the other ***** ***** who did place the order. I promptly called Blair again who put on another supervisor so I explained the whole mess again for the umpteenth time and of course she assured me she would straighten out. I understand this woman paid by check on her order of October 10, and it looks like she probably does not still have her order being they are still contacting us, the other ***** *****, my mother who never placed the order in the first place. I am ****** *****, daughter of ***** *****, a senior who is not proficient on the computer which is why I am writing to you. We will not order from any of their stores again.

Desired Settlement: Please advise me you have contacted Blair to let them know of this contact so they will take repeated calls to their customer service seriously. The order number is ******** for the other ***** *****, also in Downers Grove, IL.

Business Response:

 

Thank you for forwarding the above referenced complaint.

 

We have been in contact with Ms. ***** to apologize for the many mix-ups caused by an order processing error that was made on an order placed by another ***** ***** who also lives in Downers Grove, IL 60515.

 

We have made the proper corrections, and we have taken every possible step to ensure that this will not happen again.  We are also sending Ms. ***** a $50 Gold Violin gift card as a gesture of our goodwill and sincerest apologies.

 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Customer Care Specialist

Office of the President

 

 

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

Regards,

 

****** *****

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

11/4/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: About 6 months ago I purchased 3 pairs of pants(pair of sweats at 29.00 and a pair of capris and a pair of jeans at 24.99 each). I finally received all three. I ended up returning the pair of jeans though for a different size. I received 2 statements telling me when delivery date would be for the jeans and they never arrived so in Aug I spoke to a rep at Blair to cancel the jeans and she would waive the late fee off my bill since I never rec them after returning them and she would adjust the bill. The next month my bill came in for 66.00 w/a late fee of 25.00 and I just rec this months bill for 78.00. I spoke to another rep in Sept and was told they will deduct what I didn't purchase and any late fees. I then got a letter from them saying they deducted 3.00. Who is doing the math there? According to my records, I told them that I should owe them 13.00 plus ship/handling. It appears they will keep sending me bills and include late fees. They are unwilling to work w/me. Thank you for your time. ***** ******

Desired Settlement: It would be nice if they would stop sending me bills and w/late fees. I am willing to pay them 13.00 plus ship/handling which is according to my records the balance I owe them for the other 2 pairs of pants...not 78.00. If you want copies of the bills, letter stating they took 3.00 off account, the checks that I paid to them, I would be happy to send them your way. Thanks again.

Business Response:

 

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from Ms. ******.

 

Charges were made to Ms. ******’ account for $58.22 and $13.99 for a total of $72.21.  Credits for $11.25 and $3.00 were issued to her account totaling $14.25.  The difference between the charges and credits is $57.96.  That amount was for the White Denim-Eze Capris (24.99), Heather Gray Sport Pants (13.99), shipping and processing (9.99), and a SmartPost return label fee (8.99) when she chose that method to return the merchandise.

 

In the interest of customer satisfaction, we are processing an additional credit of $18.98 to remove the shipping and return shipping charges from Ms. ******’ account.  We have also contacted Comenity Capital Bank on her behalf and asked them to remove their charges, reinstate her credit limit, and clear the incident from her credit report.  Once all credits have been issued in approximately 4 to 8 business days, the balance on Ms. ******’ account will be a credit balance of -$1.02.

 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this complaint is appreciated.

 

Sincerely,

 

***** ** ******

Office of the President

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

10/17/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Would like a refund of the gift cards I purchased May 12 2013 on Order Number ********. The cards were purchased as a mother's day gift and totaled $150.Over two weeks ago my mother called the company to place an order (Order ********). The representative told her the card numbers were not valid. The clerk said someone would call her about them. After 3 phone calls, they still could not agree the cards were valid.I had a e-chat (Oct 8), sent a tweet (Oct 10), and a phone call (Oct 11). The first one said her manager would have to review it. The second one (****) said she had taken the original call from my mother and had escalated the issue to management. They don't understand what is wrong with the cards. She was going to escalate it to management and said I should expect a phone call that afternoon.There has been no phone call or refund to credit call.

Desired Settlement: Please refund the $150 from Order Number ******** and explain to me how this circumstance will be prevented from happening in the future.

Business Response: Thank you for providing us with the opportunity to respond to Ms. ********'s complaint with your office. We have reviewed our files and find that the two gift cards are still valid and we do not show previous correspondence having been received from her. To resolve the matter we are voiding the original gift cards and issuing a refund to Ms. ********'s credit card. This credit should appear on her credit card account shortly. We are sorry for the difficulty she and her mother had with the gift cards and we hope this will resolve the matter to Ms. ********, her mother, and your offices satisfaction. 



If we can be of further assistance regarding this matter, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We appreciate this opportunity to be able to resolve this matter.


Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.   

Regards,

 

 

****** ********

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

9/30/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
9/25/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I have made numerous telephone calls requesting the customer service department to discontinue sending me Appleseed's and affiliate catalogs. It's been close to a year since my original request and I am still receiving catalogs.

Desired Settlement: STOP mailing catalogs to my address immediately.

Business Response: Thank you for contacting our office on Ms. ****'s  behalf. We have reviewed our files and do not find a request from Ms. ****'s to be removed from our mailing list and our sister companies. We have removed her name and address from our files at this time. Since our mailings are prepared in advance to be sent to our customers she may receive a few more until the name removal takes full effect. We have also contacted our corporate offices to make sure Ms. ****'s name and address are removed from our files at all levels. 


We hope this will resolve the matter for Ms. ****'s and your office. If we can be of further assistance, please don't hesitate to contact our office.


BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

9/25/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I made the mistake of ordering a jacket from this company without checking them out first. Placed a phone order and recieved the item without a problem. The fit was awful and mailed it back 26august2013 with their prepaid label the cost to me 8.99 aloss. NO TRACKING NUMBER, NO HELP FROM CUSTOMER SERVICE, ONE PERSON TOLD ME THERE WAS A TRACKING NUMBER ON MY RECIEPT. HOWEVER THE US POST OFFICE CONFIRMED IDEED THER WAS NO WAY TO TRACK IT. NOW I AM INFORMED BY APPLESEED'S THAT ATTENTION IS GIVEN TO OUT GOING PACKAGES NOT RETURNS. I MAY HAVE A REFUND IN ANOTHER 2 OR 3 WEEKS.BOTTOM LINE: IS THEY KEEP MY MONEY IN THIER BANK AND I CAN'T EVEN CONFIRM WHEN THIS PACKAGE WAS RECIEVED BY THEM. CLEVER, UNETHICAL PRACTICES LIKE THIS NEED TO BE STOPPED. THANK YOU,****** *********

Desired Settlement: payment was put on our Visa cardjust want it back and to never hear from these people again.

Business Response: Thank you for providing us the opportunity to respond to Ms. ********'s complaint. We have reviewed our files and find that we have received her return for which a credit of $60.61 is currently processing and should appear on Ms. ********'s credit card account within a few days. A fee of $8.99 was made for the use of the Return Label used to return the merchandise. We are removing this charge at this time and a second credit in the amount of $8.99 should appear on her credit card shortly. We hope this will resolve the matter to Ms. ********'s satisfaction. If we can be of further assistance, please don't hesitate to contact our office.



BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

9/23/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues
9/3/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I returned an item that they shipped to me that I did not order. They shipped the wrong item. They continue to bill me for the shipping and the item. They are also charging me interest I have called and wrote them and they will not stop trying to collect money from me.

Desired Settlement: I want the bill reversedOrder # *************** #*******************

Business Response:

 

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from Ms. ******.

The merchandise she returned was credited to her account on 06/17/13; however, there were remaining charges totaling $16.98 for shipping and processing (5.99) and Protection Plus (2.00) that are not credited when merchandise is returned, and a SmartPost return label fee (8.99) when she chose that method to return the merchandise.

Due to the misunderstanding, our remaining charges have been removed from her account.  We also contacted ******** ******* Bank on her behalf to remove their charges.  The current balance on Ms. ******** account is now $.00.

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter for Ms. ****** is appreciated. 

 Sincerely,

 ***** ** *****

Office of the President 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/30/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Back in May I ordered clothing items from them using the internet. I just noticed that my credit card is being billed $14.95 a month for something called " Blair Rewards" which I did not want. I called and talked to 3 people getting no understanding of how these charges occurred and for what service. They "assured" me that the charges will be refunded on my credit card, but I don't feel reassured since all I have is a verbal confirmation. I could not get them to send me an email/letter so that I have concrete evidence. I don't want to wait for at least a month to check my next credit card to find out if they're telling me the truth or not.I checked on the internet and found out that many other people have had the same problem I am experiencing. What can be done NOW to get this taken care of? I am very concerned!

Desired Settlement: I explained this above.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your August 23rd letter forwarding the complaint of ******* * *******, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.

On August 28th we called and left a message on Ms. *******’s answering machine to explain. We told Ms. ******* that her Blair Rewards membership was canceled on August 23rd and a full refund ($14.95 X 3 + $1.95 = $46.80) was issued to her credit card.      

Ms. ******* enrolled in our Blair Rewards program when placing an online order on our website on May 4th.  After placing her order she was offered an opportunity to save $15 off her next Blair purchase simply for trying a membership in our Blair Rewards program. At no time was she ever obligated to accept the membership offer, and her Blair order was not contingent upon her accepting the offer. 

To enroll in the program, Ms. ******* clicked offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, conditions, and costs of the program.  It was on this page that she entered her email address, zip code, and clicked on the ‘Join Now’ button. Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established. Of course, once she enrolled, she could have canceled the program at any time with no further obligation. This program is no longer being offered to our customers. 

As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

Sincerely, 

**** * ********

Compliance Coordinator  

Consumer Response:

I am unable to respond to the message in your "normal manner".  I will be happy IF I receive the refund on my credit card.
   I still say I have received absolutely NOTHING ----not even any information ---about these "rewards".  I have no idea what this "offer" means. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

8/27/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I called Blair in June 18th. 2013 to cancel 14.95 rewards membership and yesterday we received a bill for 14.95 plus late fee dues on their credit card called Blair classic. Saying we now owed a total of 30 dollars for the membership for the $14.95 plus late fee of 19.95 and I called blair to tell them this was the 3rd time I called to cancel rewards membership and the said I had to call ###-###-#### to see about the late fee charge and they told me I had to talk to Blair. So I'm not sure how to cancel the late fee charge because the blair account is in my Mom's name ******* ****** and I don't want to have her end up with it messing her good credit rating. Her and I live together so our phone and address is the same. I need help making sure this $19.95 charge is cancelled and to make sure they know we don't owe the total of 30 charge because we cancelled back in June and they said nothing about calling and making sure there was no late fee charged and yesterday we got a bill saying we owed $30 dollars the Date we received this bill yesterday 8-19-2013. We would appreciate any help to see about getting this resolved for us. Thank You so much!!! We didn't appreciate the run around blair is giving us. Thank You so much for any help you can give us to definitely get this resolved.

Desired Settlement: Just to resolve so we don't owe any money or late fees and to keep my Mom's great credit rating and so we don't receive further bills or notices.I called Blair and told them to take us off their mailing list. We no longer would like to deal with Blair.

Business Response:

Dear Ms. ******: 

 

We are in receipt of your August 20th letter forwarding the complaint of ******* *** ****** on behalf of her mother, ******* ******, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond. 

 

On August 26th we called ******* ****** and left a message to explain that on June 19th her mother, ******* ******** Blair Rewards membership was canceled and a partial refund of $14.95 was issued to her mother’s Blair Credit Card account. In interest of customer satisfaction, and to resolve this matter, on August 20th we issued credits for the remaining charges ($1.95 + $14.95).  Since ******** Bank administers our Blair Credit Card accounts we asked them to remove any fees associated with these charges, which they have done. There is now a small credit balance on her mother’s Blair Credit Card account. 

 

As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

 

Sincerely, 

**** * ********  

Compliance Coordinator  

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me.   

 

Regards,

 

 

******* ******

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

8/21/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Placed an order & all items were returned with the exception of a top for $9.95. Was billed for shipping, interest and collection costs now totaling over $167. Too much to pay for a top on sale!!!

Desired Settlement: Willing to pay for top & it's shipping cost & interest. Unwilling to pay additional collection fees & other fees.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ******* ********.

We have no record of Ms. ******** previously contacting us about this matter.  Our remaining charges were $51.50 for the top she kept (3.59), shipping (27.98), return label fees (17.98), and Blair Rewards (1.95).  In the interest of customer satisfaction, we issued credits for all remaining charges.  We also contacted Comenity Capital Bank on Ms. ********** behalf regarding their charges.  They assured us that she would not be held responsible for the late fees and finance charges on her account.

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter is appreciated.

Sincerely, 

 

***** ** ******

Office of the President 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/19/2013 Problems with Product/Service
8/15/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
8/15/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: For 20 years have been ordering clothing from Blair. Always filled out orderform in catalog and sent personal check as payment. About 2 years ago, company started harassing me with phonecalls insisting that I had a credit account, and then a credit card. At 95 years old, I have NEVER had a credit card nor do I ever want one. They insisted that I did, and after MANY phone calls finally they promised that I would not be charged the service fees for the credit card I never had nor wanted to have. Thought we were done with this mess, but in March of 2013, a subsidiary? of Blair, Holstead Jewelers of Bolingbrook, IL 60490-9818 sent me several packages of cheap costume jewelry which I did not order or want. They were all sent back to them and after many phone calls to that company (whose credit system is hooked up with Blair Corporation)"Rose" promised me on March 25, 2013 that I would not receive any more correspondence from them and that my information would be purged from the system. Now yesterday, they have been calling me and some young man from what he said was a "bank" was VERY insistent and would not stop harassing me. I finally gave in and gave him my last 4 digits of my social security number. I am afraid and scared. Please help me.

Desired Settlement: Just get these companies to stop harassing me, I have never had a credit card and don't want one! Please get them to take my entire information (especially my social security number) out of their entire system. And NEVER to harass me again.Thank you.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from Verna Hankee. 

When Ms. ****** signed the acceptance card (copy attached) for the free item offered, she was enrolled in a continuous marketing program.  This authorized us to send periodic shipments of merchandise to her and bill her Blair Credit Card account.  If she did not return the customer service card that accompanied the free item asking us to cancel her from the program, the merchandise continues to be sent every one or two months.       

The jewelry was all returned; however, there were shipping charges remaining.  We removed the remaining charges, and we contacted Comenity Capital Bank to remove their charges.  They verified that they have done so, and they also verified that Ms. ******** account has been closed and the Credit Reporting Agencies have been notified to update their records.  Ms. ******** account was opened in 2003 when Blair had our own in-house credit.  We sold our credit portfolio to World Financial Capital Bank (now known as Comenity Capital Bank) in 2005.  

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter for Ms. ****** is appreciated. 

 

Sincerely, 

 

***** ** ******

Office of the President  

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/14/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: On June 23, 2013, I got online and purchased a $25- gift card that was supposed to be emailed to my mother for her birthday. They debited the $25- from my account on 6/25/13. After waiting several days, my mother never received the gift card. I contacted the company at the phone # listed on the debit on my checking account(that # is ###-###-####). They said that it would be taken care of. I have contacted Blair almost once a week since then, requesting they take care of getting my mother this email. I finally told them just to email it to my email address. They agreed, I still never received it. I contacted them again, today 7/19/13. I asked for a manager, they stated they have no protocol to get ahold of a manager, no phone #. Only email and that they would email their manager again. Told them I didn't beleive they couldn't get ahold of management and angrily asked them to email me while I was on the phone with them or credit my account. Connie stated that was not protocol and she would have to email management again. I have made at least 4 phonecalls to this company regarding this. I told them I would turn them into the better business bureau.

Desired Settlement: I want my $25.00 credited back to my account!!!!!

Business Response:

July 30, 2013 

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ****** *****.  We tried to reach her by telephone, but we were unsuccessful. 

 

We are truly sorry for any inconvenience she was caused regarding the Electronic Gift Card she ordered for her mother.  The first gift card was sent on 06/24/13 to ********************, and the second gift card was sent on 07/22/13 to *********************************  Either the email addresses were incorrect, or the gift cards may have ended up their spam folders if their computers did not recognize our email address. 

 

Ms. ***** has been fully reimbursed for both $25.00 charges.  A credit of $25.00 was issued to **** on 07/23/13 for the first charge, and a credit of $25.00 was issued to **** on 07/29/13 for the second charge.  Both gift cards have been deactivated. 

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated. 

 

Sincerely, 

 

***** ** ******

Office of the President 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/14/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I placed an order with Gold Violin on 5/31/2013 for;1 Travel Wheel Chair #***** $239.001 Brush #***** $39.001 Bath Bench #***** $65.00I returned the bath bench immediately, due to was not stable and safe to use. I called and verified they received the bath bench mid June. Since mid June, I have been calling and expediting my credit for $65.00 almost daily. Everytime I call I am hearing different promise date for the credit. Purchase was made on debit, and per my bank, credits are processed as soon as they are received daily. As of today 7/19/13 credit has not reached to my account. I called Gold Violin this morning, as usual they promised to do it today.Gold Violin is a very poorly managed, very unreliable mail order business.People should think twice before placing any orders with Gold Violin.

Desired Settlement: I would like to receive $65.00 credit immediately.I promise not to place any more orders and advise everyone I know with this experience.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your July 19th email forwarding the complaint of ***** ****, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond. 

 

On July 30th we called and left a message on Ms. ****’s answering machine to apologize and inform that two refunds ($56.01 and $8.99) were issued totaling $65.00. This reimbursed her for the defective Bath Bench she returned.  

 

Return refunds do not generally take this long to process from the date the customer returns the merchandise; however, on July 1st we instituted a major upgrade to our computer systems, and unfortunately, this may have caused a slightly longer processing time and for this we sincerely apologize. 

 

As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

 

Sincerely, 

**** * ********

Compliance Coordinator  

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/13/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I placed an order with Blair for a total of $75.78.Through my **** they have charged me $163.55An over charge of $87.76I have written to them twice to receive what they owe me and get no response.

Desired Settlement: I would like a refund by check.

Business Response:

 

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from**** ****.

 

 

Ms. **** returned two bras for an exchange to a different style bra.  A credit was issued for the returns, and the replacement order was charged to her credit card when it was shipped.  We have attached an itemized statement of both orders showing the charges to her credit card and the credit that was issued.  We hope this will clear up the misunderstanding. 

 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated. 

 

Sincerely, 

 

***** ** ******

Office of the President 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/13/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Ordered 4 items on 4-9-2013. Two of the 4 items received, but two were backordered and to be shipped on 6/17/2013. To date (7/20/2013)the backordered items have not been received.

Desired Settlement: The two backordered items should be shipped to me immediately or a refund should be issued in the amount of 71.98 plus tax.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ****** *******.

We are truly sorry that two of the items Ms. ******* had ordered were unavailable.  Both items were canceled when we did not receive a response to our second backorder notice, and a refund check for $75.96 was sent to her on 07/08/13.  However, the refund check has not yet been cashed.  If she did not receive it, she should contact our office at ###-###-####. 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated. 

Sincerely, 

***** ** ******

Office of the President 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

8/9/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: On June 18th I ordered an 8 ft. outdoor awning. It cost me $269.15. I received it about 2 weeks later, the wrong size. They cashed my check but didn't deliver the correct awning. I called them and talked to ******. She said that *** ** would call me when they were going to pick up the old awning and she would send me the correct size. Didn't happen. I called about two weeks later and talked to ****** & asked why they hadn't picked up the awning. She didn't know, after some conversation she said it may be because they got a new computer. She said they couldn't deliver the correct awning until they picked up the mistake. I said I'd like to know when they'll be here and she didn't know. I asked for a supervisor to call me. She put me on hold and said the supervisor Miss ******* would check on the order and call me back. She never called back. This week I called again and they have no answers. I told them I want to know when they'll pick up the wrong awning and deliver the correct awning. Summer will be over and I won't need it. I feel this is not my fault, they have my money and I don't have the product. This is very frustrating and I'd like to get it resolved.

Desired Settlement: I would like the correct awning, as soon as possible. If not they can return my money.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your My 29th letter forwarding the complaint of ***** ****, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.

On My 31st we called and spoke with Ms. **** to apologize, and to inform her that a call tag had been issued. She was happy to learn that ***** would be there to pick up the package on August 1st. In our conversation, we promised to refund her once the awning was picked up, and on August 2nd a refund of $254.15 was issued to her credit card for the 8’ Window Awning.

We called Ms. **** again on August 6th to inform her that a refund of $254,15 was issued to her credit card on August 2nd for the awning she returned.

 


As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

Consumer Response:

I did get a response from Solutions. Tha gal said the return was never ordered and she would do it right away. She would then give me credit once she knew the return was picked up. That I wouldn't have to wait until it was delivered back to them. 
 
I thought that was good until I got a $15.00 credit posted to my bank account two days after the pickup. I panicked and wondered if that was all they were going to credit me since they owed me $269.15.  
 
So I had to make another phone call to them and they said credit would take up to a week to show up. I said then why did the $15.00 credit show up? They didn't know but I think the $15,00 credit was for shipping.  
 
I did finally get the full credit yesterday 8/7.  Now I'm happy and I don't ever want to deal with Solutions Catalog again!
 
Thank you for your help!
 
***** **** 
 



 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

7/31/2013 Delivery Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Paid for items which shipped on 6/16/13. They never showed up but post office showed as delivered. I have a locked mailbox so wasn't stolen. I called CS to discuss. Response is:"We show it delivered". When pressed by me they said, "you can have it refunded, or re-sent, but not until 30 days has passed. It's our policy". Is that on your website? "No, but that's our policy". She suggested I contact the post office for tracking. Postal carrier tried everything to find it (including hanging a note on the mailboxes in case it was placed in the incorrect one, but could not find. So I called after 30 days to reorder. I requested *****, not "***** ****" to avoid any further issue & was told ok. I was willing to pay, but she indicated she changed it to ***** without the extra charge(they should, since they've had my money for 5 weeks and I have nothing to show for it). She said they would email when shipped. I saw they've charged me again & I've received no email confirming the order or shipment. I called to question charges and status. Response:"You are refunded the old charge and then newly charged". OK,where is the refund? It hasn't shown on my card. "Sorry but we show refunded". Asked her, sending *****, right? "No-***** ****". Woman I spoke with said she changed it to ***** for me. "Well, she didn't-sorry". Fine-please change it to *****. "No, too late". Why not, it hasn't shipped yet? "Yes it has". Where is my email? "It shows you were emailed." I wasn't. Can you send another email? "No-unable to, but when it's shipped, you'll get one". Since I have no email yet and you said it was "ready to be shipped", that means I can change the delivery. "Nope. Sorry". She was a BIG FAT LIAR (all the discrepancies in one phone call from her lips) and terrible customer service. I still don't know if it's been sent or if I've gotten a refund because although she says it has shipped and I have gotten the refund, I have no evidence of either of those, despite being charged now, twice, for the same order.

Desired Settlement: I want the refund for the original order I never received, which the CS agent said has happened, but hasn't.I want replacement items sent to me via ***** (not ***** ****) if it hasn't left the company warehouse yet.I want communication of the status of the order.I also want an apology from a manager at the company for the terrible treatment of a paying customer.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your July 18th letter forwarding the complaint of ****** ******, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.

When a package is reported lost, we ask our customers to allow the post office 30 for delivery, this is normal procedure. Once the 30 days are up, and the customer has checked with the post office, we issue a refund for the first package, and then, we enter a new order. We do not charge for the new order until the package is shipped. 

We are sorry to learn of the problems Ms. ****** experienced with regards to her June order.  On July 15th when she contacted us we issued a refund of $97.13 to her credit card, and entered a new order for the four camis. We called and spoke with Ms. ****** on July 30th to apologize, and she confirmed receipt of both the package and the credit.  

 As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

 Sincerely, 

**** * ********

Office of the President 

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and have determined that this does not resolve my complaint.  For your reference, details of the offer I reviewed appear below.

From the company:"When a package is reported lost, we ask our customers to allow the post office 30 (days) for delivery, this is normal procedure". My response iscompanies who care about customer service do not think it's normal procedure to make the customers, first wait for 30 days, then make the customer check with the company's shipping agent when that company's agent has lost the package.  Also, although it may be their normal procedure, they do not post that policy anywhere so the consumer has a fully informed choice about whether they are willing to wait 6 weeks for potentially lost orders and then to have the onus on them to do the footwork of tracking it for the company. Further, to wait 30 days when the package could have gone coast to coast 4 times over in that amount of time is unreasonable.

From the company:"Once the 30 days are up, and the customer has checked with the post office, we issue a refund for the first package, and then, we enter a new order. We do not charge for the new order until the package is shipped." My response to that is: I take exception to both of these statements. First, I was recharged before the items had shipped. I was charged on a Monday and there was no communication to ***** for pick up until Friday evening 4 days later. Second, the refund showed up in my account 2 days after the recharging, not before the recharge. Further, upon my request and offer to pay, I was told the order would be shipped regular ***** and therefore trackable. It came *********, not *****, so it was a full 10 days before receiving the re-order. Unacceptable. 

They exhibited very poor customer service with no offer of any type of consolation. I will not do business with them again. If you read the reviews from other consumers, there are numerous complaints of a similar nature. They apparently don't care enough about their bread and butter customers to make small tweaks in the way they treat them so that the general opinion of them would improve and they would get more repeat business. 

And the most disturbing fact of all.....the BBB shamelessly gives them an A+ rating because this company pays them, despite over 200 complaints against them. Shame on the BBB

****** ******

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: After reviewing the position of all parties, BBB determined that the business made a reasonable offer to resolve the complaint. However the consumer did not accept the offer.

7/19/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I placed an order with Blair for my 89 year old aunt and was told there wouldn't be any problems returning the item. I did have to return it and have the email stating they received it. The problem is that my aunt is receiving a bill. When I talked to them a couple of weeks ago they said she owed them $150 for shipping and handling and interest charges. We sent the items back and they said they charged for shipping it to us and us shipping it back and then they shipped it back to us and we had to return it again and was told they charged her for that also. I made several phone calls and sent a couple of emails asking about these charges and was told they couldn't remove these charges but would talk to a supervisor and see if they could remove the charges and let me know. Well I received another bill this week for $68.59. Previous balance was $150.17 and they issued a credit of $118.20 and then charged $35 for fees and $1.62 interest and a past due amount of $31.97. I am not sure what else to do or say about this but I believe it is a scam they run on the elderly people thinking they will just pay the bill. They called my aunt several times and have upset her so much. She keeps telling them she doesn't owe them that she returned the items. I have documentation that they received these items back and credited her account. A couple of months later they send her a bill for over $60 and then it just keeps going up from there. I have ordered from other companines and never had problems returning something. I would really appreciate any help that you can give me with this problem.

Desired Settlement: I just want them to remove all charges and stop calling and billing my aunt for something we don't have.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from******* *****.

We apologize for any inconvenience Ms. ********* was caused.  The original shipping and processing charges including Protection Plus (if requested by the customer) are not credited when merchandise is returned, and there is a fee of $8.99 for each use of the return label that is attached to our packing slips.  The fee is shown on the front of the label, and an explanation of the fee is shown on the back of the packing slip.  Our customers are under no obligation to use the label.  They can return merchandise on their own by using the delivery method of their choice. 

In the interest of customer satisfaction, credits are being issued to remove all remaining charges from Ms. *********** account.  We have also contacted ******** ******* Bank, the owner and administrator of the Blair Credit Card, to remove their remaining charges and clear the incident from Ms. *********** credit history. 

 Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter is appreciated. 

 Sincerely, 

***** ** ******

Office of the President 

Consumer Response:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID ******* and have a question.   Just to make sure I understand this reply, does this mean my aunt doesn't owe anything or does this mean she needs to pay the $8.99 shipping charge? The letter stated the $8.99 charge and that they would remove all remaining charges so I just need to make sure if I need to pay this or not.  I didn't see this on the label or in their return email that sent me stating they received the items we returned.

Thank you so very much for helping me with this issue.  This is the very first time I have ever filed a complaint and very impressed with the way BBB has worked with me. 

Regards,

 

******* *****

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

7/18/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Have been buying from your company for many years. I ordered 4 shorts recently and they were not as good as quality as usual. In fact one was very poorly sewn. I was willing to exchange the product for another one but when my daughter called for me the lady told her that they will charge me 8.99 to do so. When she asked her why I should have to pay for exchanging or returning something that was poor quality she told her that "nothing in this world is free".

Desired Settlement: I would like the product replaced without having to pay more to have that done.

Business Response:

 

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from **** ******.  We tried to reach him by telephone, but we were unsuccessful.

 

We are truly sorry for the inconvenience we caused him.  The return label fee should have been waived since the shorts were poorly sewn.  We are sending Mr. ****** a letter with a postage paid return label attached for his convenience in returning the shorts for an exchange or credit. 

Your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter is appreciated. 

Sincerely,
***** ** ******
Office of the President 

 

 

 

 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

7/18/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Complaint Details Unavailable
7/12/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: The company advertises its products as having an unconditional lifetime guarantee. In 2009 wy wife, ********, bought the ultimate in lounging Floating Hammock. The fabric of the product has not held up well here in AZ. We caalled the company and asked them to stand behind their product. They will send us a new one if we send the old one back. That seemed all right until I tried to do that. It would take a box that would be at least 6' by 4' by 4' and the weight is approximately 85 pounds. It is too big and heavy for the USPS. UPS said it would have to go by freight and would cost over $850.00. I looked on the ***** websight and the cost htere would be over $5000.00. I think this is ridiculous for a product that cost $299.99. My wife called and talked to ***** twice on Monday and I believe ****** twice, the first time on Monday, and they say there is nothing they can do to help. ****** had said she would call my wife back the next day but did not until Thursday after I went on their web site, Wednesday evening, and asked about it. Why not accept a picture of the problem. We are worried that if someone sits in it the fabric will tear and the person will get hurt. This has not happened. Both of us are under the weight limit for this product. She bought it before we were married under the name ******** *****. She was told by ****** that the order # was *******. ****** could not find it under that number. She asked if we could just get the swing part and was told they don't send parts, only the whole product. WE has done business with a lot of companies and this is the first time we have filed a complaint.

Desired Settlement: We would like a new product without the expense and hassle that we have been getting.

Business Response: Please see attached response 

Consumer Response:


---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: *** ******* ***********************
Date: Fri, Jul 12, 2013 at 2:27 PM
Subject: Re: ReopenCase *******
To: ******* ******* ********************


***** sent me a letter stating they would cover three of the nutritionist sessions, April 5, April 9 and April 15. They said there would be a check mailed out within 15 days of that letter which was dated June 13, 2013.


Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

Regards,

****** ******

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

7/11/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I have been trying for months to opt out of their Blair Rewards Program. I'm not even sure how I got in this in the first place. I have sent emails and called numerous times. They keep charging my account $14.95 each month. When you call no one seems to know how to deal with this problem. They just send you from one person, and phone number, to another. They always say someone will get back to you - but they don't. They say a simple phone call or email is all it takes to opt out of this program but neither is true. Yesterday I actually was shifted around to four different people and phone numbers - none of which seemed to be able to help me. I have become so frustrated that I did a search on line and found out that there's a huge number of people having the same problem with this Award Program. People are finding these charges on their bills just because they ordered from this company and many with the same problem that I have. They just simple will not let you out of this. I have been ordering from this company for years and never dreamed that they would be part of such a scam - but this is a SCAM and a big one by what I have read online.

Desired Settlement: I simply want these charges to stop. If they don't then I will file another complaint and at that time will request every $14.95 amount charged on my account be reimbursed.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your June 18th email forwarding the complaint of ****** *******, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond. 

 On June 26th we called Ms. ******** to explain that after she made her February 12th purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Blair purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Blair Rewards program.  At no time was she ever obligated to accept this membership offer, and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon her accepting the offer. 

To enroll in this program, Ms. ******** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Blair Rewards. By entering her email address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a membership in Blair Rewards.  Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established. Of course, once she enrolled in the program, she had the option to cancel the membership at any time with no further obligation. 

 Per Ms. ********** request, her membership was canceled on May 20th.  In interest of customer satisfaction, we issued three refunds of $14.95 each to her credit card on June 18th for the monthly membership fees. 

 As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

Sincerely, 

**** ** ********

Compliance Coordinator

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

7/10/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Called March 4,2013 to cancel receiving catalog. Was told I would receive 1 or 2 more before they will stop. I have received 5 more catalogs and 2 envelopes and it is late June. I called May 20, 2013 to see why I was still receiving the catalogs and to confirm original cancellation date. Cancellation date was confirmed. I called again June 5,2013 to ask why I am still receiving catalogs. I was told that it has been entered to stop mailing catalogs. Called again June 21, 2013 and was told that the cancellation was entered into the system June 11, 2013. I was also told that the cancellation takes 6 months and yet I was also told that I would only receive 1 or 2 more catalogs. So which is it? I want the catalogs to stop and I want them to stop now.

Desired Settlement: I want the catalogs to stop immediately. I was originally told that I would receive 1 or 2 more and that was not the truth. I was told that it takes 6-8 weeks before the catalogs stop and that was not the truth. Then I was told that it takes 6 months before the catalogs stop and that is probabaly not the truth either. And besides, 6 months of receiving catalogs after you have requested them to stop is an excessive amount of time.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ****** *****. 

We apologize for the inconvenience she is being caused by the Appleseeds catalogs she is receiving.  We were able to reach her by telephone to explain that she had two customer numbers and it appears that she was marked for removal on 06/11/13 when she called us.  Ms. ***** stated that she was removed on 03/04/13.  We contacted Appleseeds, and they agreed that it looked as though she was already flagged for no mailings.  They did add Ms. ***** to their Do Not Mail list; however, they said she will be receiving a few more catalogs until she is completely removed.

We are hoping Ms. ***** will allow some more time for the removal to take full effect, and again, we apologize to her for the inconvenience.

We appreciate your assistance in helping us to resolve this matter for Ms. *****.

Sincerely,

***** ** ******                                                                                                                             
Office of the President


BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

7/9/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Complaint Details Unavailable
7/9/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I made an order online for an e gift card to be emailed to my mother for the amount of fifty dollars. On their website it says that the e gift cards are emailed the same day they are ordered. However, nothing showed up an either email account. When I called to ask about this, I was informed by a very rude person that it showed it to be shipped on the 28th of June. I found this odd because it wasn't suppose to be shipped and was suppose to be emailed. When I called the second time, I was told again that it was shipped and that the matter would be taken care of. After a few days of nothing appearing, I contacted them via email and was met once again with rude service and told that it had shipped and I had to wait. Once more this was odd. Finally, I called again on the 8th of July and spoke to a supervisor who did not seem to have much more manners then the service representatives. I was informed by her that there was no shipment put out on the 28th and that none of the previous information I had given them was listed on the file. I was then told that it was sent out again the 2nd and that she was unsure what happened and it must have something to do with the holiday. When I asked to speak with the people in charge of that department, she said that she couldn't talk to them directly either and reassured me a message would be sent.

Desired Settlement: I would like my fifty dollars refunded back to me since I have not received my gift card and do not wish to deal with their rude customer service again.

Business Response:

Thank you for sending us the complaint you received from ******* ********. 

We are truly sorry for the mix-up regarding the E-Card Ms. ******** ordered to be sent to her mother’s email address.  The E-Card has been deactivated, and a credit of $50.00 is being processed to **** ending in ****.  The credit should show in her account in approximately five business days. 

We spoke to Ms. ******** earlier today, July 9th, to apologize and verify if she wanted a replacement or credit.  We are also sending her a $25.00 gift card as a gesture of goodwill and our sincerest apologies.  We were unable to locate the telephone calls she made to Customer Service under the telephone number we have on file which is ###-###-####.  If she called from a different telephone number, we would appreciate her giving us that information by calling ###-###-####. 

Your assistance in this matter is appreciated. 

Sincerely, 

***** ** ******

Office of the President 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

6/27/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I purchased a few items from the Blair catalog which I received in the mail from Warren PA. These items were very inexpensive and small. I did not find out until my husband began noticing automatic and reoccurring charges of $14.95 for the past several months with the charge of 'reoccurring rewards'. I did not authorize or agree to this whatsoever. I called Blair's customer service and they said that they Take care of this, have it cancelled, and refund my account. Nothing happened for another moth and I incurred the same automatic withdraw. I called again and this time could not connect with the customer service department and was dropped into voice mail which gave me several recorded prompts, one of which was to cancel the online rewards program. I hit the prompt to respond to the cancel and received the automatic message that the prompt had been acknowledged. Once again, another month and another charge. I tried calling again, and once more wound up in the never ending prompts.After months of attempts to try and get this resolved, I had no choice but to contact my bank's fraud department, explain the fraudulent charges, have my bank account with my credit card closed.Is this the way that customer's are treated? Really? I have not had a late payment of any kind in over 35 years, my credit rating is excellent, so why does one have to deal with such shady and deceiving tactics? I went so far as to perform a google search on this 'rewards' charge associated with Blair and found 100's of hits. This is an outright scam. You people have the nerve to rate this company good? What stats are you looking at?

Desired Settlement: I want my funds returned and I want this information escalated to their management which I'm sure are well aware of this scam and actually are probably condoning it. This needs to be logged into your BBB system, because it is absolutely impossible to believe that you have not heard of this before. Or maybe you like Corporate America turns a blind eye to us hard working honest American citizens. **** ** ****

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your June 6th email forwarding the complaint of **** * ****, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond. 

 On June 11th we left a message on Ms. ****’s answering machine to explain that after placing an placing an order with one of our associates on October 28, 2010, she was presented with an opportunity to accept a membership in Blair Rewards for a full 30 days.  This offer included receiving, in the form of a gift code number, $20 off her next Blair purchase.  At no time was she ever obligated to accept the membership offer and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon her accepting the offer. 

The representative taking Ms. ****’s order is required to inform all customers of the program terms before asking them if they would like to accept it.  Any customer who is interested in the offer is asked to enter the last four digits of their telephone number on their telephone key pad to confirm their acceptance.  It is explained to the customer that after the first 30 days, the membership will automatically continue for a membership fee of $14.95 per month, billed by us as Blair Rewards to the same credit card, unless the customer asks to be canceled from the program.  Cancellation may be made at any time with no further obligation.   

 Ms. ****’s membership was canceled on June 6th and a full refund was issued - twelve credits of $14.95 each were returned to her credit card, and two refund checks ($179.40 and $106.60) for the remaining nineteen months plus the $1.95 activation fee were processed to be sent to her ******** ** address. 

 As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer with the resolution of her complaint. 

 Sincerely, 

**** ** ********

Compliance Coordinator 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

6/26/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I recived an offer by mail stating that I would get $14,95 off my next order. Now I am getting $14.95 charged each month to my account. I called and got myself off of the program, but then I found a whole page on the internet of complaints about the same thing. I would like to get the money back for the 2 months I was charged.

Desired Settlement: I would like my money back, but I would really like for them to stop doing this to others.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your June 19th email forwarding the complaint of ******* ****, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.


On June 26th we called Ms. **** and told her that two refunds of $14.95 each ($29.90) were issued to her credit card as she requested for The Tog Shop Rewards program.  We explained some of the benefits of the program and told her we no longer offer this program to our customers.


As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.

Sincerely, 

**** ** ********

Compliance Coordinator 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

6/17/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Solutions offers products for the home. When product arrives, so does packing material with notification that the consumer has purchased a "reward" program. Without the consumer's signing up for the program, a charge of $14.95 is added to the consumer's credit card. I noticed mine after I had paid it for five months (******** ******* agreed to eliminate the charge for the sixth month). The only way to cancel this "service" is to call the company. ******** ******* is blocking further charges from this on line provider to me.

Desired Settlement: It would be nice to get a credit back, but what I really want is for you to give this company the bad name it deserves.

Business Response: Please see attached response 

Consumer Response: Better Business Bureau:

Although I do not believe that I ever clicked on such an offer, the matter has been resolved to my satisfaction. I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. 

Regards,

***** *******

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

6/14/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: On May 16 I received items I ordered from the Tog Shop, order no.********, ordered 5/6/13.The advertisement at that time stated free shipping, The invoice with the shipment advised me to phone ************** to get a "free shipping rebate on this order"Upon phoning I was asked for my name. address. credit card number,social security number, When I inquired why they needed this informationit appeared that they were setting up a credit card account in my name.Of course I do not want another credit card and the free shipping amount they were going to send me for this priviledge was $15 even though I was charged $18.99. Of course I refused to open an account and forfeitedthe so called free shipping. And they use a devious way to ensnare customers into opening a credit account.

Desired Settlement: I want other customers to be made aware of their practices and this information to be published. And i want a check for $18.99

Business Response: Thank you for providing us with the opportunity to respond to *** ******* complaint. Upon reviewing her order # ******** which she placed on our website we find that she did not provide a free shipping code when placing the order. Therefore, the shipping was charged to her in the amount of $18.99. An offer is provided on the packing slip which accompanies the order providing the customer with an opportunity to apply for a free shipping rebate through ****************. To receive the rebate the customer must join the Free Shipping Program and apply for the rebate through them. As a courtesy to *** ***** we have processed a credit in the amount of $18.99 to her ******** ******* Card which was used for payment on the order.  This credit should appear on the customer's credit card account within a few days. We hope this will resolve the matter to *** ******* and your offices satisfaction. If we can be of further assistance to you, please don't hesitate to contact us. 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

6/13/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Blair signed us up for "Blair Rewards". We never requested "Blair Rewards" We are billed $14.95 a month TWICE on two separate credit cards. This has been going on since 2011. We have been charged almost $800.

Desired Settlement: We would like the money to be repaid.

Business Response:

On May 29th we spoke with ********* and informed him that he has been fully refunded for all charges made for the Blair Rewards program. Twenty-four credits of $14.95 each were returned to his ******** cards. Since his wife used two different ******** cards, one half of the credits will be issued to each of them.  The remaining twenty-five months, plus the two activation fees of $1.95 each are being sent to his wife via refund checks totaling $377.15.  

We explained to *** ********* that his wife ********* had enrolled in two separate Blair Rewards programs. Her first enrollment was on December 9, 2010 after placing a telephone order. At the time she enrolled, our representative would have explained the terms, conditions, and costs of the program to **** ********* prior to asking for her verbal agreement.  After verbally agreeing to the program, she would have been asked to enter the last four digits of her telephone number on her touch tone key pad as her electronic signature. Had she not verbally agreed, and entered the last four digits of her phone number, she would not have been enrolled in the program. 

The second time she enrolled was on July 23, 2011 when she placed an internet order. After placing her order, she was offered an opportunity to save $15 off her next Blair purchase simply for trying a membership in our Blair Rewards program.  At no time was *** ********* ever obligated to accept this membership offer, and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon her accepting the offer. 

To enroll in this program, *** ********* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Blair Rewards. By entering her email address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, *** ********* activated a membership in Blair Rewards. Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established. Of course, once the customer enrolls in the program, they may cancel their membership at any time with no further obligation. 

Since we believe in customer satisfaction, we were privileged to assist *** ********* in resolving this matter by providing a full refund for all charges made for the Blair Rewards program. 

Sincerely, 
**** * ********  

Compliance Coordinator

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

6/13/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Complaint Details Unavailable
6/5/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I returned (and requested an exchange) for an night gown. I provided my new credit card #, which was another debit card, from another bank, (**** **** ****** ** *******). The initial card (also a debit card) was from ******** **** ******* and I shut that account down before the exchange was processed. Therefore, upon the exchange the company claims to have given the refund to my account "** ********" After much running back and forth to see where my refund is, neither, ******** say that they can give me a refund, nor Blair/Orchard Brands. (I have stated to Blair several times that they should just reprocess the refund and they refuse to do so at 'my' request). I have also told them that, since I am an employee they can even just include it on my next paycheck which would be fine as well, especially since they have access to my banking information via direct deposits. I have even given them the suggestion to print out a paper check and send it to me, but still they refuse to process the amount of $42.00. (******** tells me that since the account was closed (and no new ones were opened and it is not 'credit' card) then there is obviously no account to place the funds into. I was (am still am not) even a client of ******** anymore. Therefore, I am under the impression that Orchard Brands (Blair ?) owes me my refund money. ....(They already charged my new bank acct for the exchange and no problems "taking" my money) but they still refuse to reprocess 'any' form of refund for my returned item. The reference # that you may need is: ***********************. (I got the run around so many times and it became so time consuming because of refusal on both businesses behalves that I decided to wait until my final exams were over @ school). Please help me.

Desired Settlement: I would like a refund in any way shape or form that it can come in from whomever it should come from. ******** they do not owe it to me and Blair / Orchard Brands told me the same thing. However, it is clear that 'someone' owes me my own money.

Business Response: Thank you for providing us the opportunity to resolve the dispute made by Ms. ******. In reviewing the order we find that a refund was issued to the original form of payment on her **** Card in the amount of $42.00 on December 12, 2012 for which we received a confirmation number of *********************** for the credit. The bank is responsible for refunding the customer once the credit has been received and processed to the account. Since the funds were not returned to ***********, a further refund was not due. To resolve the matter to both Ms. ****** and your office satisfaction we are having a cash refund issued to her which should be received within seven to ten business days. We appreciate the opportunity to be of assistance in resolving the matter. If we can be of further assistance please don't hesitate to contact us. 

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

6/3/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I returned a jacket because it was too large. I wanted an exchange but they were sold out. I called customer service and was told a refund was sent to my bank. I have not received the refund.

Desired Settlement: I would like the $95.99 returned to my account.

Business Response: In regard to the attached complaint for ****** ********, we appreciate the opportunity to assist you in resolving the matter. *** ******* returned a size Xlarge Petite ********** ********* and requested a size Large Petite which is currently on order for her. We were unable to obtain an authorization for the charge from her Credit Card Company in order to ship the exchange. When a return is received a credit is processed to the original form of payment less the return label fee of $8.99. A credit of $87.00 is currently processing to *** ********** credit card and should appear on the customer's credit card account within a few days. Once the credit for the return processes it may enable to exchange order to process for her if her credit card account has enough funds for the charge. We attempted to reach *** ******** regarding the exchange to see if she was still interested in receiving the coat but were unable to get an answer to our calls. We are currently holding the exchange order awaiting the return credit to completely process and verification from *** ******** if she still wants to receive the exchange order. We hope this will resolve the matter to both *** ********** and your office satisfaction. If we can be of further assistance, please don't hesitate to contact us.

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

5/7/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: In October, 2011, I purchased an item from Blair Clothing Company. Next, I received an email that my Blair Rewards Membership was active. It contained a password, member ID, and code for $15 off my next purchase. I just assumed that it was one of these "points" programs that many stores have. Nowhere was it mentioned that my credit card would be billed $14.95 a month! I used the code, but ended up returning the item. Now my credit card has been billed $14.95 every month since October 2010, and I have never shopped at this store. I have called and left messages to end this membership, as it is hard to get someone on the phone.When I finally was able to talk to someone today, I was told that when I made my purchase and clicked "continue" I enrolled in this program, and agreed to pay $14.95 per month. This is a scam - I don't even know what benefits this membership is supposed to provide (that would be worth this monthly fee). I have asked for a refund, and was refused. I have never received any further correspondence from this company - they just keep billing my credit card.

Desired Settlement: I would like this company to end my "membership", delete my personal information (especially my credit card information), and refund me the nineteen months of $14.95 fees that they took from me.

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your April 26th e-mail forwarding the complaint of *** ******, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond. 


On May 6th we left a message on Ms. ******’s answering machine to explain that after she made her September 21st purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to accept a Blair Rewards membership offer, including a gift code number representing $15 off her next Blair purchase, compliments of Blair Rewards.  At no time was Ms. ****** obligated to accept this membership offer and her Blair purchase was not contingent upon her accepting the offer.


To enroll in this program, Ms. ****** clicked on the offer and was taken to a webpage that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Blair Rewards. Ms. ****** was also advised, in clear visual proximity to the acceptance button, that by entering her email address, zip code and clicking the acceptance button, she was activating a membership in Blair Rewards. Had she skipped any one of these steps no membership would have been established.  Of course, once she did enroll, she could have canceled her membership at any time with no further obligation.

 

We are pleased that Ms. ****** was able to use the $15 gift code on her September 30, 2011 purchase. 

Per her request, we canceled Ms. ******’s Blair Rewards membership on April 25th and issued a full refund (19 X $14.95).  Twelve refunds of $14.95 each were returned to her credit card, and a refund check of $106.60 was sent to her for the remaining charges ($14.95 X 7 + $1.95). 

 

As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

 

Sincerely, 

**** ** ********  

Compliance Coordinator  

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

5/3/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Both Appleseeds and the TOG shop are charging my credit card $14.95 for some unknown reason.I want my money back. I did not sign up for these extraneous charges. This is over and above the cost for any merchandise. I called Appleseeds but after transferring me around to different people, they finally hung up. PLEASE PLEASE CAN YOU GET MY MONEY BACK AND MAKE THEM STOP.I AM GOING TO (FINALLY) CONTACT THE CREDIT CARD COMPANY TO STOP THOSE CHARGES TO THE CARD.I ACTUALLY DO NOT KNOW HOW LONG THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON. IT WILL TAKE SOME TIME TO GO THROUGH THE CREDIT CARD HISTORY. HOWEVER, I'M SURE THEY ALSO HAVE THE INFORMATION ON WHEN THEY TOOK A MONTHLY 14.95

Desired Settlement: STOP STEALING MONEY FROM MY CREDIT CARD. AND GIVE ME THE MONEY BACK!

Business Response:

We are in receipt of your April 8th email forwarding the complaint of ******* * *********, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond. 

 

On April 17th we called and left a message on Ms. *********** answering machine to explain that after making purchases on our websites (both Appleseed and Tog) in 2011, she was presented with the opportunity to save $15 off her next purchase simply for trying a membership in our Rewards program. At no time was Ms. ********* obligated to accept these membership offers, and her purchases were not contingent upon her accepting the offers.   

 

To enroll in the programs, Ms. ********* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of the Rewards program. By entering her e-mail address (*************************), zip code (*****), and clicking the acceptance button, Ms. ********* activated a membership in the rewards program. Had Ms. ********* skipped any one of these steps when she placed her orders, no membership would have been established.  Of course, once she did enroll; cancelation could have been made at any time with no further obligation.  

 

Ms. *********** memberships in both the Appleseed’s and The Tog Shop Rewards programs were canceled this week, and refunds for 23 months at $14.95 each were issued to her credit card and three refund checks ($14.95, $179.40, and $74.75) were sent to her *********** address for the remaining eighteen months. 

  

As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

 

Sincerely, 

**** * ********

Compliance Coordinator  

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

4/29/2013 Problems with Product/Service | Complaint Details Unavailable
4/19/2013 Problems with Product/Service
4/16/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: WinterSilks has been processing a $95.88 membership fee (without my knowledge)on my ******** ***** ******* credit card for the past three years. In 2010 I ordered two pair of socks on clerance. I have never received anything stating I would be charged a "membership fee" for placing a one time order. The product was a waste of money. I did not realize WinterSilks was processing this $95.88 fee until last week when I received my **** statement. I immediatley called my **** company to file a dispute, and called WinterSilk (*************** demanding to know who authorized this transaction. The representative, told me we charge your **** every year since you placed the first order? I never authorized this, and have never received any type of information from your company in three years. He removed the fee except for $9.72, which my **** company is disputing. The confirmation #********. I looked into my statements from 2011 and 2012 only to discover they processed the fees in those years too.

Desired Settlement: I know that this company is committing fruad and stealing from the consumers. When I ordered there was no mention of a yearly $95.88 membership fee. I would have never placed an order for two pairs of socks, (on clearance), that would end up costing me over $100 dollars. That makes absoultly no sense. Besides the socks only lasted a couple months before they had holes in them. There needs to be an investigation into WinterSilks. I would like the 2011 and 2012 unaurthorized fee of $191.76 returned to me in the form a a check. My **** company is handeling the 2013 dispute. They recommended I contact you and have the BBB handel the past two year unaurthorized fees. I appreciated your assistance in this unlawful matter. Thank you. ******** *******

Business Response: Please see attached response 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

4/12/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Apparently when I purchased some stair carpet pieces on May 24, 2012, I used a 10% off coupon. I have just learned that if you didn't look at the fine print and check a box that said "Do not purchase NTO solutions reward program", you started getting charged 14.95 every month (my credit card was charged 6-25-12, 7-25-12, 8-24-12, 9-24-12, 10-24-12, 11-24-12, 12-24-12, 1-23-13, 2-22-13, 3-26-13). My husband thought this was a ******* charge and didn't not show me the account until today (we divy up duties). I called to cancel the membership, but initially they would not refund any of the charges. I have never used this program and I would prefer to be refunded for the entire 149.50. Since I unknowingly accepted this program in the devious fine print of the coupon, I realize that this is my issue and they did eventually say they would refund $59.80 (however I have not see this yet), but only after a lot of hassling. They basically said I was the one that had the problem, but reading through complaints on the internet, this has happened to numerous people. There was no obvious recognition of this program on my receipt that came with this purchase and I had no idea that I was in a rewards program.

Desired Settlement: I want this practice stopped so that people like my grandparents do not get caught in this trap. There was no information regarding this program or I would have never signed up for this. I will not shop here again, but I want this on their record so that if some poor soul complains about a similar issue they get their full refund.

Business Response: Please see attached response 

Consumer Response:

Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response made by the business in reference to complaint ID *******, and find that this resolution is satisfactory to me. I appreciate the company's effort to address this complaint, however their description of signing up for the rewards program is inaccurate.  I hope they continue to try and improve customer service as this type of complaint should not need to be filed with the BBB for resolution. 

Regards,

****** *****

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

4/11/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: In December 2011 my wife purchased some goods from Sahalie. On 3/31/2013 as I was reviewing one of our credit card bills, I noticed a $14.95 charge to Sahalie Rewards. Upon further research similar chaarges ($14.95) were on this credit card dating back to January 2012, and with a charge in December of 2011 of $1.95. We did some research on the internet (Complaints Board) and found similar complaints from many other customers. I contacted our credit card company and was informed to make contact with Sahalie Rewards to try to gain a resolution, and if unsuccessful to contact our credit card company again. My wife did contact Sahalie Rewards on 4/1/2013. The rep was less than hospitable, and after strongly suggesting I must have made the purchase and signed up for the program, and after disputing her accusations, the rep finally agreed to cancel my wife's subscription and refund only the current months charge, which was still pending, however she would do nothing for the past charges. (I did call our credit card company and advise them of the status and they did agree to place a block on any further charges from Sahalie Rewards.) The summary of the issue is we did not sign up for the Sahlie Rewards Program and did not authorize these charges to our credit card!

Desired Settlement: 1. Refund of $226.20 ($14.95 x 15, plus $1.95).
2. Confirmation that the pending charge from 3/31/13 was credited.
3. Confirmation that subscription to Sahalie Rewards Program has been cancelled.
4. Confirmation that our name has been removed from all mailing lists for both Sahalie Rewards and Sahalie.

Business Response: To Whom This May Concern:
We are in receipt of your April 2nd e-mail forwarding the complaint of Mr. ***** *******, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On April 4th we called and left a message on Mr. *******’s answering machine explaining that after placing his December 29, 2011 purchase on our website, he was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off his next Sahalie purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  At no time was Mr. ******* obligated to accept this membership offer and his Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon him accepting the offer.
 
To enroll in this program, Mr. ******* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards. By entering his e-mail address (********@********.com), zip code (*****), and clicking the acceptance button, Mr. ******* activated a membership in Sahalie Rewards.   Had Mr. ******* skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established. Of course, once enrolled Mr. ******* had the option to cancel his membership at any time with no further obligation.
 
Per Mr. *******’s request, we canceled his Sahalie Rewards membership on April 1st and a refund of $14.95 was issued to his credit card.  In interest of customer satisfaction, we refunded the remaining charges on April 2nd.  Of these refunds, eleven refunds of $14.95 each were returned to Mr. *******’s credit card, and a refund check of $46.80 ($14.95 X 3 + $1.95) was processed to be sent to his ***********, IN address.
 
As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of his complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response does satisfy my issues and/or concerns in reference to complaint.

While the refunds satisfy our request for resolution, it should be noted that the statements made in the Sahalie Rewards response memo are not accurate.  We did not EVER knowingly agree to or intend to agree to joining their program.  Furthermore we did not authorize any payments to them for this program.  It is disappointing Sahalie would allow their rewards program to be managed in such a fashion.  Thank you for your quick response to resolving this issu.

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

BBB Comments: The consumer indicated to BBB that the complaint was resolved.

4/1/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
3/26/2013 Problems with Product/Service
3/26/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
3/26/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I placed an order with this company and without my knowlege they started charging me for a rewards program I never authorized at 14.95 a month. I have tried to contact their customer service who has given me the run around telling me I have to contact a reward supplier in India. When I called them they ask me for more of my personal information rather than stopping the continued charges of $14.95. I have contacted my credit card company but they can only give me credit for two months not the 12 months I have been charged for. Also I had to cancel my card and order a new one causing me to be without my credit card. When I looked up NTO Solutions which is what the charge appears on my credit card their are pages on the internet of this scam for a reward program that is unathorized. Please help me.

Desired Settlement: $149.50

Business Response: Please see attached 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

3/20/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: My wife has occasionally ordered products from Sahalie clothing magazine for a few years. Each time, she has unwittingly agreed to sign up for the Sahalie Rewards program, and we were charged an extra $14.95 per month. She has tried to cancel repeatedly, but somehow we continually end up getting charged for it. Agreement to sign up for these extra charges per month are in no way clear in the process of normal purchase of clothing, and it is very misleading. Further, beginning on January 9, 2013, Sahalie began charging an additional monthly fee. $1.99 in January, and then 14.97 thereafter. Again, my wife did not knowingly agree to these charges. Looking back through my credit card billing, Sahalie has been charging us for services that we did not agree to for over a year. My wife requested a refund for these, but Sahalie agreed only to refund the last month. Sahalie's marketing practices are misleading and constitute a scam. This was a flagrantly dishonest means of collecting further money from an unsuspecting customer, and it appears to be standard business practice for the company. Given the large number of other users who have reported identical issues through both the BBB and other websites, my wife's experience is not unique.

Desired Settlement: I would like my money back for all previous charges for their "rewards" program and VIP rewards program. I also find it distressing that a company with repeated complaints of blatant dishonesty of an identical nature is able to maintain an A+ rating in the BBB; I would like to see that rating go down until they fix their marketing scheme.

Business Response: To Whom It May Concern:
We are in receipt of your March 13th e-mail forwarding the complaint of ******* ********, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On March 18th we called and spoke with Mrs. ******** to explain that after placing an order on our website on December 11, 2011, she was offered an opportunity to try a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  To enroll in the program, she clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards. On this page she entered her email address, zip code, and clicked on the acceptance button to enroll. Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.  Of course, once enrolled, she can cancel the program at any time with no further obligation. 
 
At her request, her membership was canceled on March 13th and a refund of $14.95 was issued to her credit card.  In interest of customer satisfaction, we issued refunds for the remaining charges on March 14th.  Eleven refunds of $14.95 are being returned to her credit card, and a refund check of $46.80 ($14.95 X 3 + $1.95) is being sent to her.
 
In 2012 we launched a new loyalty program called Sahalie VIP Plus.  Mrs. ******** enrolled in this program after placing an order on our website on January 2nd.  In speaking with Mrs. ******** she told us that she remembered the Sahalie VIP Plus program offer, but may have misunderstood about canceling. Since customer satisfaction is important to us, we canceled her membership in Sahalie VIP Plus and issued a full refund of $31.93 ($14.97 X 2 + $1.99) to her credit card.
 
Enrollment in either one of these programs is purely voluntary; however, once a customer does enroll, they have the option to cancel their membership at any time with no further obligation.  As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of their complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** * ********
Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response does satisfy my issues and/or concerns in reference to complaint.

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

BBB Comments: The consumer indicated to BBB that the complaint was resolved.

3/20/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
3/19/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Solutions sent an unsolicited catalog to my home. They sell "products to make life easier" Nowhere on the cover of their unsealed catalog does it indicated that the products within may be inappropriate for children. They have a full page of sex toys. My daughter brought in the mail and flipped through the catalog as she often does with catalogs. I am appalled and disgusted that she was exposed to these products in such a way and feel that this company is running an unethical business practice for including these products and not sealing and marking the catalog as such. And for sending it to me in the first place.

Desired Settlement: I think they should be fined and required to remove the adult products from their inventory and to donate 100% of the proceeds from the adult products for the last 18mos. to the ******* ** elementary school.

Business Response: See attached

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

3/18/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
3/11/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues
3/10/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
2/28/2013 Problems with Product/Service
2/22/2013 Problems with Product/Service
2/22/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
2/15/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues
2/15/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: In January I realized there was a charge from Sahalie Rewards of $14.95 against my credit card about which I was unsure. Upon checking my prior statements, I saw that the charge of $14.95 had been made every month since October, 2011. As there was an 800 number listed on the bill, I called that number only to find out that it was not in service. Next I called the Sahalie Catalog Company and was told that that theirs was a separate operation but they gave me the number for Sahalie Rewards. I then called the new number and was told that they had no record of me. I asked to speak to a supervisor. None was available, but they took my name and number in order to have one call me back. 48 hours later I received the call. Again I was told that it was not their area of operation and was given another number. At this point I decided to check the Better Business Bureau site. It turns out that I am not the only person that has had problems with this company. The other complaints are the same as mine. At no time do I recall authorizing or signing up for Sahalie Rewards. If I actually did sign up, it was not evident that I was actually signing up or for what. Obviously since they make it so impossible to resolve an issue with them, they are aware that their method of operation is not totally above board.

Desired Settlement: A full refund for the 15 months of $14.95 charges.

Business Response: To Whom It May Concern:
We are in receipt of your January 23rd e-mail forwarding the complaint of ******* *****, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On January 30th we left a message on Ms. *****’s answering machine to explain that after she made her October 26, 2011 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Sahalie purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon her accepting the offer.
 
To enroll in this program, Ms. ***** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a membership in Sahalie Rewards. Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.   Of course, once she enrolled, she had the option to cancel her membership at any time with no further obligation.
 
Per your request, we canceled Ms. *****’s Sahalie Rewards membership on January 10th and issued a full refund.  Four refunds of $14.95 each were returned via chargebacks made to your credit card.  Eight additional credits of $14.95 each were issued to your credit card, and a refund check of $31.85 ($14.95 X 2 + $1.95) was processed for the remaining charges.
 
As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

2/13/2013 Problems with Product/Service
2/12/2013 Problems with Product/Service
2/11/2013 Problems with Product/Service
2/5/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues
2/1/2013 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: In late November, 2012 I purchased a dress online from a company named "Sahalie". The dress arrived late December, 2012. Today, January 23, 2013, I noticed on my bank statement that I am being charged $14.97 per month for a "VIP" program that I know nothing about. I called the company and was informed that I was enrolled in this program when I made my original purchase. I was directed to another phone number to "cancel" the "VIP" program. When I phoned the second telephone number, I was told that I must have filled out an "enrollment" form when I made my original purchase. This I did not do. I did not see anything that spoke of this "VIP" program and the representative told me that he could cancel my membership but would not reimburse the two months I was charged. I explained that I did not fill out an enrollment form and that I did not sign up for their VIP program. The representative just told me to have a nice day.

Desired Settlement: I would like the total amount of $31.93 charged to me for the VIP program that I did not enroll in. This is the amount that the Sahalie representative told me that I have been charged thus far. I have also contacted my bank to dispute these unauthorized charges.

Business Response: To Whom It May Concern:
We are in receipt of your January 23rd letter forwarding the complaint of ***** *****, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On January 29th we called Ms. ***** to inform her that her Sahalie VIP Plus membership had been canceled, and a full refund ($14.97 X 2 + $1.99) had been issued to her credit card.
 
Ms. ***** enrolled in our Sahalie VIP Plus program after placing an order on our website on November 17th.  At that time, she was presented with the opportunity to save $15 off her next Sahalie purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie VIP Plus program.  She was not obligated to accept this membership offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon her accepting the offer.
 
To enroll in this program, Ms. ***** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie VIP Plus. By entering her e-mail address, zip code, and clicking the “Join Now,” she activated a membership in Sahalie VIP Plus. Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.  Of course, once enrolled, the customer may cancel at any time with no further obligation.
 
As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** * ********
Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response does satisfy my issues and/or concerns in reference to complaint.

I would however like to clarify portions of the conversation that the Sahalie representative described having with me.  She (****) did assure me that a full refund was being made to my account and that the membership they had signed me up for had been cancelled.  ****'s letter to the Better Business Bureau describes a process that I enrolled in their program which is completely false.  There is no enrollment process that they describe, nothing that opens a separate web page and describes this program and the subsequent ongoing cost and it is insulting that their company is promoting this scam without the knowledge of their customers. 

I do accept the outcome in that the "membership" has been cancelled and my money refunded but still do not appreciate that they continue to lie about their inappropriate methods of enrolling customers in their phony "VIP" program.

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

BBB Comments: The consumer indicated to BBB that the complaint was resolved.

1/31/2013 Advertising/Sales Issues
1/28/2013 Problems with Product/Service
1/22/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
1/15/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
1/4/2013 Delivery Issues
1/4/2013 Problems with Product/Service
1/2/2013 Billing/Collection Issues
12/31/2012 Problems with Product/Service
12/25/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
12/21/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
12/20/2012 Problems with Product/Service
12/18/2012 Problems with Product/Service
12/5/2012 Problems with Product/Service
11/21/2012 Problems with Product/Service
11/18/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: Apparently in June 2009 after I made a purchase, I was "duped" into signing up for a "rewards program" for $14.95 per month, with a 30 day free trial, along with an offer of $20.00 off my next purchase. Unfortunately, and shame on me, I just now picked up on it when I received my credit card statement that the fee was charged to. I never intended to sign up for the program, and if I did receive anything in the mail about it later, I would have thrown it away because I would not have been interested. Just another example of a borderline "unethical" business practice of giving you a "free trial" of something that they hope you will forget about and not call to cancel and end up being charged for. This slip on my part has now cost me over $600. over more than 3 three years with an automatic charge to my credit card. It would be obvious if my sales records are checked that I never have bought enough to make a program like this advantageous to me and that I would not have signed up for it.

Desired Settlement: A refund of money I never intended to spend. There should be some requirement that companies that automatically bill you for something be required to periodically contact you to verify that you intend to continue the automatic billing.

Business Response: To Whom It May Concern:
We are in receipt of your November 8th email forwarding the complaint of **** * *****, and we appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On November 16th we called and left Mrs. ***** a message to inform her that a full refund has been issued for all charges totaling $644.80.  Three credits of $14.95 each were issued to her credit card on November 7th when her husband called to cancel her membership.  The remaining 40 months at $14.95 each plus the $1.95 activation fee were refunded on November 8th.  Nine of these credits ($134.55) were refunded to her credit card, and the remaining $465.40 is being sent to her via three refund checks ($179.40, $179.40, $106.60).  The refund checks will be sent in a standard size off-white envelope with her name and address in the window as the addressee.  The return address will show EMI – Encore Marketing International with their Maryland address. 
 
Mrs. ***** enrolled in Sahalie Rewards after placing her May 20, 2009 order on our website.  At that time she was presented with an opportunity to accept a membership in Sahalie Rewards for a full thirty days for $1.95.  This offer included receiving, in the form of a gift code number, $20 off her next Sahalie purchase, compliments of Sahalie Rewards.  She was not obligated to accept the membership offer, and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.
 
The representative taking Mrs. *****’s order is required to inform all customers of the terms of the program before asking them if they would like to enroll.  Any customer who is interested in the offer is asked to enter the last four digits of their telephone on their telephone key pad to confirm their acceptance.  It is explained to the customer that after the first 30 days, the membership would automatically continue for a membership fee of $14.95 billed monthly by Sahalie Rewards to the same card unless they ask to be canceled from the program.  The customer is not obligated to remain in the program, and could have canceled her membership at any time with no further obligation. 
 
We left our telephone number on Mrs. *****’s answering machine in case she further questions, or other concerns.  As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response does satisfy my issues and/or concerns in reference to complaint.

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

BBB Comments: The consumer indicated to BBB that the complaint was resolved.

11/16/2012 Problems with Product/Service
10/30/2012 Problems with Product/Service
10/22/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
10/16/2012 Problems with Product/Service
10/12/2012 Problems with Product/Service
10/11/2012 Problems with Product/Service
10/9/2012 Problems with Product/Service
10/9/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues
10/5/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
9/27/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues
9/4/2012 Problems with Product/Service
8/20/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
8/8/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
8/1/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
8/1/2012 Problems with Product/Service
7/13/2012 Problems with Product/Service
7/12/2012 Delivery Issues
7/10/2012 Problems with Product/Service
7/9/2012 Problems with Product/Service
7/3/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
7/1/2012 Delivery Issues
6/29/2012 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I had been a customer of Sahalie.com since its original incarnation as Early Winters. I noticed changes, not all for the bad, but still found some products I liked enough to order. At some point, after an online order in Aug. 2011, the company automatically enrolled me in the Sahalie Rewards program. Undetected until this month was a monthly charge for $14.95 to my **** card, dating back to Aug. 2011. I have removed myself from the program, complained to the company, and want to be refunded $134.50 for those nine months. It was a "service" I never knowingly signed up for and from which I have not benefited at all. I was billed $134.50 for NOTHING.

Desired Settlement: I think Sahalie should have disconnected from this scam artist well before now. I only discovered today by reading consumer reviews on independent websites how long it's been going on: over 4 years. They ought to be shut down or at the very least heavily fined. Too many of us have been deceived and ripped off.

Business Response: To Whom It May Concern:
 
We recently received notification of the complaint filed by ****** * ****** in May, and appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On June 27th we called and left a message on Ms. ******** answering machine explaining to her that after she made her August 16th purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Sahalie purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  She was not obligated to accept the offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon her accepting.
 
To enroll in this program, Ms. ****** clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards. By entering her e-mail address (***********************), zip code (*****), and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a membership in Sahalie Rewards.   Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.
 
Ms. ****** called and canceled her membership on May 7th.  In interest of customer satisfaction, we issued a full credit of $121.55 ($14.95 X 7 + $1.95) to her credit card on June 27th.
 
As always, it is a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.
 
 
Sincerely,
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response does satisfy my issues and/or concerns in reference to complaint.

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

BBB Comments: The consumer indicated to BBB that the complaint was resolved.

6/27/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: It was not made clear that signing up for this "rewards" program entails a monthly charge. I was under the impression that this reward program would operate like so many others - by rewarding purchases i made at Sahalie with discounts or offers.... I did not know that there was a monthly charge. I don't even believe that I had to enter my credit card information as it appears that Sahalierewards pulled my credit card number over from my Sahalie purchase.

Desired Settlement: Refund of the fees charged under this "reward" program 15 months @$14.95/month = $224.25

Business Response:

We received a similiar complaint from the Oregon BBB in April and responded with the following:


To Whom It May Concern:
 
We are in receipt of your April 2nd email forwarding the complaint of **** ******, and appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On April 3rd we called and left a message on Mr. ******** answering machine informing him that his membership in Sahalie Rewards was canceled on April 2nd and a full refund ($14.95 X 15) was issued.  Twelve credits of $14.95 each were issued to his credit card and a refund check of $44.85 was sent for the remaining three monthly charges.
 
We also explained to Mr. ****** that after he made his December 12th purchase on our website, he was presented with an opportunity to save $15.00 off his next purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  He was not obligated to accept the membership offer and his Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.
 
To enroll in this program, Mr. ****** clicked on the applicable banner ad and was taken to a landing page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards. By entering his email address, zip code and clicking the acceptance button, he activated a membership in Sahalie Rewards.  Had he skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.
 
As always, we consider it a privilege to assist our customer in the resolution of his complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator 
 

Consumer Response: I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response does satisfy my issues and/or concerns in reference to complaint.

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

BBB Comments: The consumer indicated to BBB that the complaint was resolved.

6/27/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
6/27/2012 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I just spoke with a customer service rep. as I made a $58.94 purchase on 9-15-11 & a $49.95 purchase on 10-22-11 and have been charged $14.95 every month since then for some reward program I didn't even know I signed up for. Are you people serious? I have been charged $300.00 for a total of the last 20 months and haven't ordered anything because I didn't even know I signed up.

Desired Settlement: I want a full reimbursement immediately.

Business Response: To Whom It May Concern:
 
We are in receipt of the post card you sent on June 3rd notifying us of ******* *******’s complaint, and appreciate this opportunity to respond.
 
On June 11th we called and left a message on Ms. ********* answering machine to explain the enrollment process.  After completing her September 10th order on our website, Ms. ******* was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next Sahalie purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  There was no obligation to accept this membership offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.
 
To enroll in this program, Ms. ******* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards. By entering her e-mail address (**************************), zip code (*****), and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a membership in Sahalie Rewards.   Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.
 
Per Ms. ********s request, her membership in Sahalie Rewards was canceled on April 30th and three credits of $14.95 each were issued to her credit card.  In interest of customer satisfaction, on June 8th we issued credits for the remaining four months ($14.95 X 4) plus the $1.95 activation fee.
 
As always, it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

6/22/2012 Problems with Product/Service
6/16/2012 Problems with Product/Service
6/12/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
6/4/2012 Delivery Issues
6/4/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues
6/4/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
5/25/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
5/10/2012 Problems with Product/Service
5/8/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
5/4/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
4/30/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
4/30/2012 Problems with Product/Service
4/25/2012 Problems with Product/Service
4/16/2012 Problems with Product/Service
4/10/2012 Problems with Product/Service
4/10/2012 Problems with Product/Service
4/9/2012 Delivery Issues
4/9/2012 Problems with Product/Service
4/6/2012 Problems with Product/Service | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I purchased a skirt/top from Sahalie this summer and have started to get UNAUTHORIZED****** charges out of my bank account!  I tried to call but apparently must call Monday during normal business hours.  THIS IS A
TOTALLY DISHONEST PRACTICE AND MUST STOP!!  I WILL NEVER NEVER ORDER FROM THIS COMPANY AGAIN!  Apparently there are MANY others in the country that have had the same thing happen.  Please take action!!
Thanks for helping to safeguard the normal purchasing public.

Desired Settlement: I want the charges REVERSED from my bank account and NEVER want this to happen again!!

Business Response: On March 7th we received a copy of a complaint filed by **** *** ******* and we thank you for this opportunity to respond. On November 16th we called and left a message on Ms *******’s answering machine informing her of the cancellation of he Sahalie REwards membership and the full credit ($14.95 x 4 + $1.95) that was issued to her credit card. Ms ******* accepted our membership offer after placing an order on our website on July 7th. After placing her order, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15 off her next purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program. She was not obligated to accept the membership offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer. To enroll in this program, Ms ******* clicked on the offer and was taken to a web page fully describing the terms, benefits and costs of Sahalie Rewards. By entering her email address, zip code and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a memberhsip in Sahalie Rewards. As always it has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

4/5/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
3/26/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
3/26/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
3/21/2012 Problems with Product/Service
3/20/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues
3/19/2012 Problems with Product/Service
3/16/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I learned about a charge on my credit card that triggered a fraud alert from my credit card company. I was not familiar with the name so I called the company and learned that I was a member of a rewards club that costs ****** per month. In April 2009 I made a purchase from ******* catalog; at the time of the online purchase I unknowingly agreed to a 30 day free trial for a rewards membership. After the 30 days I was charged a monthly fee of ****** to maintain membership in the rewards club. At no time was I alerted to the fact that I was a member and being charged monthly, nor was I offered any membership benefits for the past nearly 3 years. Although I check my credit card statements monthly, I focus on the larger charges and never noticed the monthly charge. I spoke with the company who agreed to reimburse 6 months of the charges.

Desired Settlement: I would like to receive a full refund from the first month charged. This is a deceptive practice. I was unaware of any membership and received no services during the time I was being charged as a member.

BBB Response: ******* ******* ** ****** **** ******* ** ***** **** ************** ******* ********

Better Business Bureau has received a complaint from one of your customers about your business.

Complaint # 8937905 was filed on 2/29/2012 4:37:27 PM by ***** ******** .

There can be two sides to every story. Sometimes complaints are caused by mistakes or misunderstandings that a business wants to know about and correct.
 
BBB is simply requesting your cooperation in making a good faith effort to resolve the complaint, regardless of the settlement explanation given by the consumer. Our objective is to assist both parties in reaching a resolution outside of the legal system.
BBB requests a response within 10 days. Please review the complaint details below and and respond to BBB and the customer using the BBB Online Complaint Management System.

If you received this complaint via email simply click on the “Respond to this Complaint”, link located on the left, when you are ready to answer. Complaint responses can be sent to BBB via e-mail, fax and mail as well.

Thank you for your cooperation.
Better Business Bureau

Please understand that the customer's complaint and your response will be publicly posted on the BBB website (BBB reserves the right to not post in accordance with BBB policy). Please do not include any information that personally identifies your customer.  By submitting your response, you are representing that it is a truthful account of your experience with this customer.  The BBB may edit the complaint of your response to protect privacy rights and to remove inappropriate language.




CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE INFORMATION

Customer Information:
Susan Elizabeth Hiller Thompson
11452 Entrevaux Drive
Eden Prairie , MN 55347

Daytime Phone: (952) 942-5514
Evening Phone: (952) 942-5514
E-mail: susaneht@aol.com


The details of this matter are as follows:

Complaint Involves:
Selling Practices

Customer’s Statement of the Problem:
I learned about a charge on my credit card that triggered a fraud alert from my credit card company. I was not familiar with the name so I called the company and learned that I was a member of a rewards club that costs $14.95 per month. In April 2009 I made a purchase from Sahalie catalog; at the time of the online purchase I unknowingly agreed to a 30 day free trial for a rewards membership. After the 30 days I was charged a monthly fee of $14.95 to maintain membership in the rewards club. At no time was I alerted to the fact that I was a member and being charged monthly, nor was I offered any membership benefits for the past nearly 3 years. Although I check my credit card statements monthly, I focus on the larger charges and never noticed the monthly charge. I spoke with the company who agreed to reimburse 6 months of the charges.
Complaint Background:
Product/Service: Rewards Membership
Purchase Date: 4/22/2009
Problem Occurred: 2/28/2012
Talked to Company: 2/29/2012

Name of Salesperson:
 
Purchase Price: $508.30
Disputed Amount: $418.60

Desired Settlement:
I would like to receive a full refund from the first month charged. This is a deceptive practice. I was unaware of any membership and received no services during the time I was being charged as a member.

BBB Response: ***** ******** ***** ********* ***** **** ******* ** *****


Dear Susan  Thompson :

This notification is in regards to your complaint submitted on 2/29/2012 4:37:27 PM against Sahalie Rewards. Complaint # 8937905.

Your complaint has been sent to the business for their response. Once the business responds to BBB, we will notify you via email and provide you with the response.

The text of your complaint may be publicly posted on BBBs Web site (BBB reserves the right to not post in accordance with BBB policy). Please do not include any personally identifiable information when you tell us about your problem or in your desired outcome. By submitting your complaint, you are representing that it is a truthful account of your experience with the business. BBB may edit your complaint to protect privacy rights and to remove inappropriate language.

Thank you.
Better Business Bureau

Business Response: To Whom It May Concern:
 
We are in receipt of the letter you sent forwarding the complaint of Susan Elizabeth Hiller Thompson, and appreciate this opportunity to explain.
 
On March 15th we called and left a message on *** ********** answering machine informing her that her membership in ******* ******* was canceled on February 29th and six credits of $14.95 each were issued to her credit card.  On March 7th we refunded another six credits of $14.95 each to her credit card and issued refund checks totaling $358.80 ($14.95 X 24).
 
We also explained to Ms. Thompson that after she made her April 22, 2009 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15.00 off your next purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  She was not obligated to accept the membership offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.
 
To enroll in this program, *** ******** clicked on the $15.00 savings offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of ******* ********  By entering her email address, zip code and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a membership in ******* *******.  Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.
 
As always is has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.
 
Sincerely,
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator

BBB Response: ***** ******** ***** ********* ***** **** ******* ** *****

**** ***** ******** *

This notification is in regards to your complaint submitted on 2/29/2012 4:37:27 PM against ******* *******. Complaint # 8937905.

The business has sent BBB a message regarding your complaint. The contents of this message are below or attached.

Message from Business:

To Whom It May Concern:
 
We are in receipt of the letter you sent forwarding the complaint of Susan Elizabeth Hiller Thompson, and appreciate this opportunity to explain.
 
On March 15th we called and left a message on Ms. Thompson’s answering machine informing her that her membership in Sahalie Rewards was canceled on February 29th and six credits of $14.95 each were issued to her credit card.  On March 7th we refunded another six credits of $14.95 each to her credit card and issued refund checks totaling $358.80 ($14.95 X 24).
 
We also explained to Ms. Thompson that after she made her April 22, 2009 purchase on our website, she was presented with an opportunity to save $15.00 off your next purchase, simply for trying a membership in our Sahalie Rewards program.  She was not obligated to accept the membership offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon accepting the offer.
 
To enroll in this program, Ms. Thompson clicked on the $15.00 savings offer and was taken to a web page that fully described the terms, benefits, and costs of Sahalie Rewards.  By entering her email address, zip code and clicking the acceptance button, she activated a membership in Sahalie Rewards.  Had she skipped any one of these steps, no membership would have been established.
 
As always is has been a privilege assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint.
 
Sincerely,
Dawn C. Sorensen
Compliance Coordinator

Please respond to this message within 10 days.

Thank you.
Better Business Bureau

Consumer Response: [A default letter is provided here which indicates your acceptance of the business's response.  If you wish, you may update it before sending it.]

Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response satisfies my
 concerns in reference to complaint #8937905. I greatly appreciate your quick response and am pleased with its resolution.

Regards,

Susan Thompson

BBB Response: **** ******** ******* ******* ** ****** **** ******* ** ***** **** **** *********

BBB has closed complaint # 8937905 as Resolved. This complaint was filed on 2/29/2012 4:37:27 PM by ***** ******** *

After reviewing the position of all parties, BBB determined that the business's response has resolved this complaint. This complaint has been closed as resolved.

No further action is required of the business for this complaint.

Thank you.
Better Business Bureau

Please understand that the customer's complaint and your response will be publicly posted on the BBB website (BBB reserves the right to not post in accordance with BBB policy). Please do not include any information that personally identifies your customer.  By submitting your response, you are representing that it is a truthful account of your experience with this customer.  The BBB may edit the complaint of your response to protect privacy rights and to remove inappropriate language.

MESSAGE:

[A default letter is provided here which indicates your acceptance of the business's response.  If you wish, you may update it before sending it.]

Better Business Bureau:

I have reviewed the response submitted by the business and have determined that the response satisfies my
 concerns in reference to complaint #8937905. I greatly appreciate your quick response and am pleased with its resolution.

Regards,

Susan Thompson

BBB's Final Determination: Consumer accepted resolution offered by the business.

3/7/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
2/23/2012 Problems with Product/Service
2/22/2012 Problems with Product/Service
2/21/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
2/7/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
2/7/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
2/7/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
2/7/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
2/1/2012 Problems with Product/Service
1/27/2012 Billing/Collection Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I ordered merchandise from Sahalie online 11/20/2011. The bill totaled $50. 75 with tax. A few weeks later I received a catalog from the Sahalie Rewards Program. I called to question what the rewards program was all about. I found out I was charged $1.95 on 11/21/2011 on my visa statement for a 30 day trial & was going to be charged $14.95 each month for signing up. I was charged $14.95 on 12/21/2011 for the program. I NEVER signed up for this program! I talked with someone from customer service at both Sahalie & Sahalie Rewards and they said I would be credited for the $1.95 and $ 14.95. They said when I ordered on line I checked that I wanted to be a member. I have not been able to find any such box when I go online! The only box that appears is already checked & it reads yes I'd like to receive e-mails & information about deals from Sahalie. This may be where they are scaming people to sign up. when I googled Shalie rewards a list of 30 some complaints came up with similar stories of people being signed up & charged $14.95 monthly unknowingly. I can only imagine how many people are unaware they are being charged!! I am hoping I receive the reimbursment they promised and would hope this practice of signing people up would be stopped.

Desired Settlement: I hope this company would be stopped from signing people up without their knowledge

Business Response: Sahalie
PO Box 146
Jessup , PA 18434

January 12 , 2012

BBB of Eastern MA , ME , RI & VT
290 Donald Lynch Blvd , Suite 102
Marlborough , MA 01752


Re: Complaint #******* , ***** **********


To Whom it may concern:

We are in receipt of your December 28 th letter forwarding the complaint of ***** ********** , and appreciate this opportunity to respond. 

On January 11 th we called and left a message on Ms. **********'s answering machine reminding her that her membership in Sahalie Rewards was canceled on December 22nd and a full refund of $16.90 ($14.95 + $1.95) was issued. 

We also explained, that after placing an order on our website on November 20, 2011 , she was offered an opportunity to save $15 off her next purchase simply for trying our rewards program for thirty days. When she clicked on the offer , she was taken to a webpage fully describing the terms , conditions , and program fees. To enroll in the program , she was required to enter her email address, zip code , and click the acceptance button on that webpage. Had Ms. ********** skipped any one of these steps , no membership would have been established. 

As always , it has been a pleasure assisting our customer in the resolution of her complaint. 

Sincerely , 
**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator 

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

1/26/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues
1/12/2012 Advertising/Sales Issues
1/11/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
1/6/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
1/4/2012 Billing/Collection Issues
11/28/2011 Billing/Collection Issues
11/24/2011 Billing/Collection Issues
11/16/2011 Problems with Product/Service
11/15/2011 Problems with Product/Service
11/10/2011 Problems with Product/Service
11/1/2011 Delivery Issues
11/1/2011 Problems with Product/Service
10/24/2011 Billing/Collection Issues
10/24/2011 Billing/Collection Issues
10/21/2011 Advertising/Sales Issues | Read Complaint Details
X

Additional Notes

Complaint: I was enrolled in your Sahalie Rewards Program 3 months ago without my knowledge. I understand that this enrollment was accomplished by an innocent click of a button on your site when I was ordering a product. I contacted ******** ******* and successfully contested the first charge but I see they are continuing. I have researched your rewards program on-line and have read hundreds of the thousands of irate customer comments regarding this unacceptable practice of scamming folks to sign up for a service supplying a third party their (our) credit card numbers, and not ending their membership even after several interactions with Sahalie Rewards and Encore.

Desired Settlement: I will simply say that I want my membership immediately terminated, my May 2011 charge of $14.99 immediately reimbursed and no further charges be made to my credit card for this service or any other service related in any way to Sahalie or ******. I expect that this will be done so that no further action will be required of me

Business Response:  
August 31, 2011


 
BBB of Eastern MA, ME, RI & VT
290 Donald Lynch  Blvd, Suite 102
Marlborough, MA 01752-4705    Complaint #     8707313
  




We are in receipt of your August 16th letter forwarding the complaint of Judy Kern, and appreciate this opportunity to response.

On June 29th we called and left a message explaining to Ms. Kern that her membership was canceled, per her written request, on June 14th and a full refund ($14.95 X 7 + $1.95) was issued to her credit card.

Ms. **** accepted a membership in Sahalie Rewards after making a purchase on our website on October 27th.  At the time of her purchase she was presented with an opportunity to accept a Sahalie Rewards membership offer and to receive a $15.00 gift code number to use on her next Sahalie purchase.  At no time was she ever obligated to accept the offer and her Sahalie purchase was not contingent upon her accepting.  Once she did accept, she was under no obligation to continue the membership and could have cancelled at any time with no further obligation.  

To enroll in this program, Ms. **** clicked on the applicable banner ad and was taken to a landing page fully describing the terms and benefits of Sahalie Rewards. Within the Offer Details, she was advised that she could activate a membership in Sahalie Rewards and start enjoying the benefits of Sahalie Rewards for the next 30 days.  

She was also advised, in clear visual proximity to the acceptance button, that by entering her email address (anibanani33@aol.com), zip code (13073), and clicking the acceptance button, she was activating a membership in Sahalie Rewards.  If she had missed any one of these steps no membership would have been established.  

While realize that our rewards program is not for everyone, we do have many customers that enjoy the program and the benefits it provides them.  Thank you for allowing us this opportunity to assist our customer in the resolution of their complaint.

Sincerely,


**** ** ********
Compliance Coordinator

BBB's Final Determination: Business offered a resolution. Consumer did not pursue further with BBB and the matter was assumed to be resolved

10/21/2011 Problems with Product/Service
10/21/2011 Problems with Product/Service
10/21/2011 Delivery Issues
10/20/2011 Billing/Collection Issues
10/20/2011 Billing/Collection Issues
10/17/2011 Problems with Product/Service
10/17/2011 Problems with Product/Service
10/12/2011 Delivery Issues
10/12/2011 Problems with Product/Service
10/12/2011 Billing/Collection Issues
10/7/2011 Problems with Product/Service
10/7/2011 Delivery Issues
9/29/2011 Delivery Issues
9/6/2011 Problems with Product/Service
1